Skip to main content

Ag & Business Legal Strategies

Enterprise Analysis: Not Just an End-of-Year Exercise

Farmer in wheat field, reading some papers

Much of the work we do is helping farmers decide how to restructure their debt and whether to file bankruptcy—and if they do file, representing them in navigating their case. We are also committed to assisting farmers and small business owners in examining their operations so that perhaps they won’t reach the point of needing to restructure their debt or file bankruptcy. This is our enterprise analysis service—which, as indicated, is for both farms and businesses, although the vast majority of our clients are farmers. The goal of farm enterprise analysis is to help the producer figure out which flows, or “enterprises,” of their business are or are not pulling their financial weight. Common enterprises on one farm might include two or more of the following: It is also possible to use enterprise analysis to determine whether to continue renting certain farmland, or whether it might be wiser to give up a lease further away for one much closer that might cost more in rent but save on fuel, hauling, and time. For growers in Iowa¹, summer is a prime time to have analysis done for purposes of renting (as the September 1 deadline looms to inform landlords or tenants of non-renewal in March 2027), and also to adequately prepare for input purchasing decisions later in the fall. Right now most of the analyses we perform are for row-crop-heavy farms, but the process is useful for any farm type. How the analysis helps It’s important to assess each individual enterprise to see if it can support itself, but also for the impact it’s having on income for the entire farm. These individual assessments usually provide surprising insights to even the most knowledgeable farmer. Recently we worked with a client to perform an analysis on each of his farm’s six enterprise flows, to help determine which pieces of equipment to keep or sell while writing his Chapter 12 plan of reorganization. We determined how much each piece was used in each enterprise—which included combining, planting, spreading manure, grain storage, spraying, and custom cattle finishing—to assign a percentage of each machine’s use to the enterprise(s) using the equipment. Then we divided the cost of the piece among them accordingly and calculated the income from each enterprise against that and its other costs. In the end, we showed many of these enterprises could not support all the equipment required to conduct that work. This is the type of process that helps a farmer decide if they should continue with a specific enterprise and, if they do, if they really need the equipment. Another good example is a farmer raising corn and soybeans, with some of the corn being used as feed for their livestock. The key question here is: What is the effective price per bushel that the farmer is receiving for what is being fed to livestock, and how does that compare to the market price it would fetch at an elevator? If the price received by walking the grain off the farm is less than the elevator payment, the farmer should ask, “Why am I continuing to feed livestock?” A secondary line of questioning would be: Is this a short-term anomaly or a long-term issue? If it is long-term, can the enterprise be turned to a profit? If not, what are the financial ramifications of ceasing the livestock operation? Would the farming operation be more profitable by either selling the crops at market price or divesting the farm of that livestock? (319) 363-1641 Honesty in outside advice It is not uncommon for farmers we work with to realize during an enterprise analysis that the numbers they’ve been working with aren’t precisely accurate. Good longtime farmers develop gut feelings about their work and the supplies they need—but when margins are as tight as they are right now, every opportunity to trim costs should be considered. We’ve heard everything from, “So I’m really not using this equipment enough to justify having it?” to, “I didn’t realize my yield estimate was that far off my actual average.” Producers confident in their cost versus profitability have been surprised, for instance, to see their actual piglets per sow per year in black-and-white, or more dry days for dairy cows between weaning and estrus than they had been figuring. This is where an outside perspective is so valuable. Farming is a business, but it’s also a calling with much emotion tied up in it—and as such, the people who do it sometimes justify unnecessary expense as a given. We provide an impartial, honest point of view that works in facts and data. It’s good to love your work, but to avoid losing money or the farm, it’s great to know your assets, liabilities, and the profitability of each enterprise on the farm. If your overall income far exceeds your costs and you can afford to keep equipment you’re not adequately using or extra livestock that costs more to feed and medicate than you earn in marketing them, you are unlikely to need our assistance. (However, even in this case, not keeping your eye on costs and profitability could lead to declining net worth and unwise borrowing later on, that could eventually result in financial distress.) If you see reduced return on investment, experience mounting debt, or otherwise feel you could better streamline your farm’s expenses, Ag & Business Legal Strategies can help you pinpoint where to make changes. Call us to find out where you’re really headed—and if it’s a good idea to pivot and change course. (319) 363-1641 At Ag & Business Legal Strategies, we want our clients to be honest with themselves and have a solid business plan. Our team will help you create and execute that business plan, and, if necessary, assist you with the legal, tax, and practical aspects of debt restructuring or bankruptcy. Don’t wait for the problems to become insurmountable. Connect with someone you can trust today, not tomorrow, when it may be too late. ¹Lease termination deadline in Iowa

Don’t Wait to See How Harvest Plays Out

Farmer figuring up his expenses

By Joseph PeifferFounding Attorney At nearly the halfway mark, 2026 is providing farmers with some of the most challenging economic times they’ve seen in a generation. This is from a combination of lower commodity prices than what they were seeing just a couple or so years ago, to increases in fertilizer, chemical, and other input costs. On the plus side, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act that Congress enacted last year contained safety net mechanisms that increased the statutory reference prices for key crops including corn and soybeans. This means higher ARC and PLC payouts are likely to be triggered. And the USDA is disbursing one-time bridge payments to some growers from a $12 billion fund announced to help offset losses stemming from tariffs President Trump put in place. On the down side, adding to the tariff-related losses and lower commodity prices are 50 percent higher fuel costs and other elevated input expenses because of the Iran war and subsequent difficulty getting products through the Strait of Hormuz. The payments mentioned above are better than nothing, but they’re a bandage — not a solid fix. Farmers would rather have stable, dependable markets for their products, than what they view as handouts. Instead, many are projected to lose money on the corn and soy acres they’ve planted this year. This is leading them to consider hard decisions, which is always better tackled sooner than later. Our office is receiving more calls than at this time last year, from farmers seeking help with debt restructuring or filing for Chapter 12 bankruptcy. I would have expected to hear from more in January or February than since mid-April, but that has not been the case. The first cash rents for the new farmland lease year were due March 1, and if a farmer was going to decide they wanted to trim their expenses or restructure debt for 2026, they had more options in January-February than they now have. Those who were unsure but pressed forward with renting to plant more anyway may have figured they could use their bridge payment to get through this season and then reevaluate after harvest. They were not expecting war nor its effect on expenses. (319) 363-1641 Potential Income Options Farmers who have significant operating capital and/or little to no debt are probably safe to weather 2026 to farm another year. That doesn’t mean they won’t lose money. But what does this year mean for those who don’t have that kind of capital and do have debt? If this is you, what can you do between now and harvest time to protect your financial interests? One of the first steps will be to review planned inputs for this summer. For example: It’s not that growers don’t normally consider this anyway, but 2026 will require even more examination of expenses versus return. If it looks like you’re only going to trade dollars one-for-one, why do it? If you can’t trim expenses enough to meet financial obligations, including loan and other debt payments, you may need to earn more income through an off-farm job, contract work such as harvesting or hauling grain or livestock for others, or finding other ways to add value to your operation. I have a client who has set up a transloading platform at his farm, where he can load crops and other commodities into containers to be shipped for export — this increases the price of his product by 50 cents per bushel. Other exporters have recently begun paying him to use the platform for their products as well. In addition, he recently attracted outside investment into opening a mixing facility to be able to ship specialized product to South Korea — an established mixing facility recently closed, so he took advantage of the brief market vacuum to fill a need. If you are a farmer with sufficient equity and liquidity, and vision, to do something like this right away, it’s certainly something to consider. But if this is not within your means and you don’t have an investor — and it won’t be, for most farmers — perhaps there is another way you can add value to your operation or find a market niche either without such a large investment. What should you be doing? If margins are tight but you are nonetheless making money this year, don’t be afraid to pay the taxes you owe. Borrowing to purchase equipment you don’t need right away, just to claim a large deduction against income and to lower taxes, might hurt you in the long run. The key here is “borrowing” — going into loan debt isn’t necessarily smarter than paying taxes, if you’re going to owe the bank for a while. If you can see that you will struggle this year to make loan payments, talk with your banker now. I can tell you after more than 40 years of this work that the farmer who comes to the bank, acknowledges their problem, and proposes how they can help solve it typically has more luck getting the bank to help them rework the loan than those who put off such a meeting. It’s never great to have the banker come to you after a default, when you had not told them that you would not be able to meet your debt service obligations. Finally, if your financial problems run deeper than one loan, it may be time to analyze operations and think about serious restructuring. Ag & Business Legal Strategies offers enterprise analysis, which reviews your liabilities and assets, revenue and expense streams, and shows you where you are losing and making money so you can decide how to move forward. If after this step you are still unsure how to proceed, our attorneys can help by reviewing options. Whether it is refiguring your operations, or needing to restructure debt or file for bankruptcy, Ag & Business Legal Strategies is dedicated to helping farmers work toward an outcome that is beneficial for their unique situation.

Our Strategies in the Headlines

Ag & Business Legal Strategies quoted in the news

By Joseph Peiffer, Founding Attorney Nearly 10 years ago, after 30 years of rural-focused practice with other firms, I founded Ag & Business Legal Strategies as a practice focused on advocating for the legal and financial interests of Iowa, Illinois, and now Missouri farmers and other small business owners facing debt restructuring or bankruptcy. This year, in the wake of more mainstream news focus on the farm economy, we at ABLS have seen a sharp increase in our efforts to provide news media with information and analysis about farm bankruptcy, financial planning, and more. Associate Attorney Austin Peiffer and I have provided multiple interviews over the past several months both to agricultural media—geared to a farmer and agribusiness audience—and to general news media that are trying to help the non-farming public understand more about agriculture. Here is a sampling of the 2025 news coverage featuring ABLS insights: We have more notable interviews to come, all with an eye toward keeping the public, as well as the farming and agribusiness communities, informed of financial and related legal factors affecting agriculture’s bottom line and future plans. If you are dealing with worry or uncertainty about debt, your financial health, or legal issues related to these, don’t wait to act—reach out for a discussion and plan of action NOW. Help yourself with the holiday gift of peace of mind! (319) 363-1641 At Ag & Business Legal Strategies, we want our clients to be honest with themselves and have a solid business plan. Our team will help you create and execute that business plan, and, if necessary, assist you with the legal, tax, and practical aspects of debt restructuring or bankruptcy. Don’t wait for the problems to become insurmountable. Connect with someone you can trust today, not tomorrow, when it may be too late.

It’s Farmers Who Suffer the Shortage of Rural Attorneys

A suited man walks through the desert

Even most attorneys enjoy a good lawyer joke. But there’s nothing funny about the shortage of access to legal representation for rural residents across the United States. And where people cannot find representation, they have a difficult time accessing justice. According to a 2020 survey by the American Bar Association (ABA), there are on average four attorneys per 1,000 people nationwide. If you have a suspicion this isn’t evenly distributed, you’d be right. Think about this: Nationwide, 40% of all counties (and county-equivalents) have less than one lawyer per 1,000 people. Fifty-four counties have no practicing attorneys at all. Earlier this year, while serving on a panel at Washburn University to discuss this shortage and brainstorm recruitment ideas, I met a fellow panelist from northwestern Kansas who is the only lawyer in her county other than its prosecuting attorney. Far from being happy about no competition, she believes the best thing for the county would be for at least one other attorney to set up practice locally. That way, she would not face so many situations in which she has to turn away potential clients because of conflicts of interest from already representing other parties involved. Also, local residents would not always need to travel to another county to hire a lawyer. Representation matters So, why are these “legal deserts” a problem—and why are they a particular obstacle for farmers and small-business owners? Regardless of where they live, everyone deserves access to legal representation and assistance when they need it. Most people hire a lawyer only once or twice in a lifetime for reasons such as divorce, writing a will, mediation, an injury claim, or bankruptcy. But if you’re running a farm or other business, occasions for need of legal assistance are more frequent than for a non-entrepreneur. A business owner works with contracts, business taxes, employees, customers, buyers and sellers, which means bringing or defending potential lawsuits or, sometimes, simply relying on an attorney to negotiate a difficult situation. While large companies typically have the resources to employ attorneys or retain the services of a big law firm, “the little guy” in need of less frequent legal services does not have a staff lawyer. For farmers especially, it is important to have access to lawyers who understand the business of farming, to help their client best navigate complex legal issues as they pertain to agriculture. This includes things like federal farm programs, farm leases and taxes, specialized contracts, ag finance agreements, incorporation papers, farm debt restructuring or bankruptcy, and more. Ag & Business Legal Strategies specializes in representing farmers—and other small-business owners—across Iowa as well as in Illinois and Missouri. Our lawyers and support staff understand the agricultural sector’s needs. We assist many clients beyond our office location, which means we rely on video conferencing in addition to some traveling for in-person meetings and court appearances. After all, the commute for a Zoom meeting is the same no matter where you live! Fortunately, courts accept electronic filing and our staff can assist clients with digitizing any paper documents as needed, allowing capable representation even for clients who live hours away. Need an ag attorney? Understanding the client When an attorney works with ABLS, if they do not already have an ag background like me (my dad was a farmer), I take them to different kinds of local farms so they can learn about cropping and livestock systems. I have even done this with some visiting lawyers. I think it’s critical for a lawyer to develop familiarity with the types of operations they will represent, plus I enjoy helping my colleagues learn the business of farming. Near ABLS’s eastern Iowa offices, legal deserts aren’t as severe as they are in western and northwestern Iowa, but there still aren’t as many attorneys as our state needs. For any profession to flourish somewhere, there must be younger people coming in to replace older professionals as they retire, sell the business, or pass away. But new graduates and other young lawyers in Iowa are moving to larger cities or out of state to work. This isn’t surprising, as many young people want access to more amenities, social networks, and career opportunities than they think rural areas may offer. I found satisfaction practicing law and raising a family in this area because, as a young attorney in the 1980s during the Farm Crisis, I saw where I could really make a difference advocating for farmers facing financial hardship and loss of their land. Even now, there are young attorneys who would like to live in rural areas, but a sense of purpose or attachment to family may not be enough incentive to someone carrying $200,000 in school loan debt, who can earn more in a large city. Some governments and organizations have instituted programs with added compensation for lawyers making even a short-term commitment to small towns. North and South Dakota each provide annual stipends for attorneys who agree to practice in qualifying counties through their Rural Attorney Recruitment Program. The attorney must live in the community for five years and be licensed to practice in that state. Each state’s legislators voted to approve the RARP, which is funded by various parties including benefited counties and state bar associations. The Illinois State Bar Association administers the Rural Practice Fellowship Program, which connects rural law firms looking for law clerks and associates with law students and lawyers interested in practicing in those areas. Associate Fellow Program lawyers are paid a one-time stipend of $5,000 when they begin working in the community, and another $5,000 if they remain for one year. Nebraska offers school loan repayment assistance through its Rural Practice Initiative—attorneys who go into private practice in a community of under 15,000 people can receive up to $6,000 yearly toward their loans, over seven years. In Colorado and Indiana, there is not compensation, but each has programs that match young attorneys or law students with mentors in rural law firms and courts, with an

Future Financial Prep ‘Tis the Reason for Enterprise Analysis

Two people looking at charts and graphs on a laptop computer

Santa Claus is a kindly old soul who makes young and old happy with gifts this time of year—but I’ve never heard of him excusing a farmer from having to prepare their taxes or submit an updated balance sheet to the bank for a loan or operating line renewal. End-of-year preparedness is a gift that only you can provide yourself. For a farmer or other business owner, December is filled with more questions than usual. Here’s a sampling: This final type of question rarely appears on its own, usually accompanied by concerns about costs, farming or business practices, suppliers, rent or facilities expenses, and much more. Not only is conducting an enterprise analysis of your farm or other business a great way to answer immediate questions, it is a necessity to provide an overall snapshot of the operation’s financial and legal health. The Enterprise Analysis You already know what “analysis” is; an “enterprise” is just a line of business or profit source. Your farm may be made up of multiple enterprises. Let’s say you grow corn and soybeans for an elevator, but you also sort, package, and market some seed—these are likely to be two different enterprises. If you also raise cattle or hogs, there’s another. Common farm enterprises include, but are not limited to: The enterprise analysis simply means examining the individual enterprises within your operation to determine the profitability of each, then isolating the factors contributing to that profit or loss so you can make informed choices going forward. Suppose you grow crops and run a farrow-to-finish hog barn. Are each of these income streams profitable? Or are the crops profitable, but the swine is experiencing losses? If this is the case, you would carefully analyze why the farrowing operation is losing money. It could be disease problems—if so, consider whether you can control the disease or should discontinue farrowing. If it is a management problem, you could consider hiring a qualified manager to oversee the operation, increasing efficiency and profitability. If the losses are in the crop operation, maybe the rent is too high on some or all leased farms. Do you lease more than one farm, but one or more property’s rent is disproportionately high, such that the lack of profitability is pulling down the profit earned on the other farms? Maybe you shouldn’t be farming that ground, and should cancel the lease when you are able. Or, if your owned land cannot support the debt load, should you consider selling some land to decrease the debt and improve the operational cash flow? This is always a controversial question, since the farmers I know would rather sell almost anything they own than a piece of ground—it’s like asking them to part with a family member. Crop enterprise analysis questions are admittedly more suited to a mid-year evaluation, since in Iowa, September 1 is the deadline to give notice of lease non-renewal. They do, however, serve to illustrate the importance of one type of analysis; and late in the year is timely for analyzing other streams of farm and business income such as livestock, meatpacking, on-farm stores, and other enterprises. Parts of the Picture Some underlying tools for enterprise analysis should be consistently updated, not just once or twice a year, which is our recommended frequency for performing full analysis. One important tool is the farm balance sheet, which you should always keep updated but is especially vital this time of year, since your bank will require it to consider your application for any loan or renewal of an operating line of credit (as Chief Financial Strategist Keith Starr covered in last month’s blog entry). As the shareholder of Ag & Business Legal Strategies, I get an updated balance sheet and P&L (profits and losses) sheet and a productivity report by an employee every week from bookkeeping. These help me gauge productivity and provide early clues about any potential problems that could impact the firm so I can course-correct production problems, spending, and collection of receivables. I highly recommend having the farm’s bookkeeping done on at least a monthly basis. This will allow you to make changes and course corrections quickly. It will also allow you to take advantage of opportunities that arise throughout the year. Keeping the books up-to-date and analyzing them regularly will help you know where you’re at and avoid guessing when you make critical decisions. It can assist you to decide whether to change spending, renegotiate debt with creditors, or change marketing plans for your farm commodities. It also makes it easier to obtain loans from creditors, when you come prepared with a solid business plan. As I mentioned earlier, December is your last chance to take action to determine the bulk of your tax strategy for this year. Now is the time to determine if you will order and prepay seed, fertilizer, and chemicals for 2025 production and deduct those expenses from this year’s income. Too, are you planning to buy or lease new equipment for 2025? Purchasing equipment can also decrease taxes. (IMPORTANT: Do NOT purchase equipment just to reduce taxes. Borrowing money to buy equipment that is not necessary can jeopardize your farm’s cash flow and long-term viability. Equipment purchases should be prudent business decisions—not reactionary decisions to minimize tax liability.) Do Regular Analyses Here’s one practical way a recent enterprise analysis can inform tax strategy. Back in the summer an analysis revealed your crop enterprise is not as profitable as you would like and you have been looking for ways to trim expenses other than rent, since the review determined that was not a major factor that can be changed this year. Knowing this and seeing that fertilizer inputs have been high for some time, you reviewed the soil test results that showed you have high levels of nitrogen and phosphorus. You decide to decrease their application rates for a year or two, knowing you can save money without harming yield or adversely affecting overall soil fertility. A

Unintended Consequences: The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022’s Farm Debt Relief Causes Farmers Massive Tax Headaches

A farmer sits at the edge of his field, holding his head as if tired or stressed out

For a deeper analysis into this topic, see a version of this article written for tax professionals and other interested parties here. On August 16, 2022, President Biden signed the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) into law. Section 22006 of the IRA provided $3.1 billion for the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) to provide relief for distressed borrowers under certain Farm Service Agency (FSA) direct and guaranteed loans. On October 18, 2022, USDA provided nearly $800 million in assistance to distressed borrowers to help cure delinquencies and resolve uncollectable farm loan debts: Unintended Consequences of the IRA Payments Farm debt relief is certainly welcome, especially to its recipients. However, when Congress authorized the IRA payments it did not consider that those payments would be counted as income for many recipients, leading to: Two Distressed Borrowers, Similar Problems Consider these two typical borrowers with FSA debts who are in currently not collectible (CNC) status, both of whom benefitted from IRA farm debt relief: Scenario 1: In 2010, Robert defaulted on his FSA-direct loan, which was secured by a lien on his property. When he could not obtain further financing, he could not continue his farming business and the loan went into default. FSA foreclosed, leaving a $100,000 deficiency judgment. Although FSA initially contacted Robert to collect on the debt after the foreclosure, the account was moved into CNC status, where it has remained for 12 years. As of 2022, his past due balance was $150,000, with interest.[1] Scenario 2: Charles has been in default on his FSA-guaranteed loan from a local bank for several years. Charles has continued to farm while working with his bank under forbearance agreements. The debt was moved to the CNC status in 2019. In October of 2022, FSA repaid his entire guaranteed loan to local bank. The payment consisted of principal of $400,000 and interest of $12,000. Now, instead of owing a long-term debt to his bank, with low payments and the option of obtaining a forbearance, he faces a large tax liability (equal to multiple years of payments) due all at once. IRA’s Effects: Increased Taxes While the IRA’s debt relief payments could have many consequences for recipients, for Robert and Charles the primary consequences are increased federal income taxes. Because of this repayment Robert could owe $24,000 or more in additional federal income taxes, and Charles $96,000. Since this debt relief was targeted at farmers who were behind on their payments, Robert and Charles likely cannot pay these bills. Current Nonviable and Viable Options Robert and Charles do have options to address their taxes, but all of them have significant downsides. However, two of the common tools for addressing these taxes are off the table from the get-go. Bankruptcy will not help Robert or Charles any time soon, because these tax debts will be nondischargeable (they will survive a bankruptcy) until at least 2026. Similarly, while insolvent taxpayers don’t pay tax on debt cancellation, that does not apply to a debt repayment like this. Robert and Charles could enter into an installment agreement to pay off their tax debts (with interest and penalties) over six year, if the IRS agrees and they can afford that additional cost. They could make an offer in compromise to the IRS to reduce the amount they owe, but that is a lengthy, difficult, and expensive process, often requiring professional assistance. Moreover, the IRS can take up to two years to review an offer in compromise. USDA is Considering Options to Assist Farmers with their Income Tax Problems. After being informed of the significant problems caused by the repayment of the debt for over 13,000 farmers, the USDA has held a series of meeting and considered three options to ease the income tax problems experienced by farmers: asking the IRS to streamline and ease offer in compromise criteria, giving farmers the option to retroactively opt out of this debt relief, and recharacterizing this debt repayment as debt cancellation instead. The USDA is also considering asking the IRS to grant IRA farm debt relief beneficiaries an extension of time to file their tax returns so they can better plan for and adapt to this unexpected income. It is also considering sponsoring professional tax assistance for affected farmers. Get the Advice You Need and Contact your Members of Congress! If you or someone you know received IRA farm debt relief but now don’t know how to deal with the tax consequences contact Ag & Business Legal Strategies today! We can assist in assessing the consequences, navigating the options, and making an informed decision. Moreover, contact your members of Congress! Tell them USDA needs to find ways to help farmers with the unforeseen tax consequences of the IRA’s farm debt relief. Download a letter template here. Read a deeper analysis here. [1] Thanks to Kristine Tidgren of Iowa State University’s Center for Agricultural Law and Taxation for Robert’s scenario.

Unintended Consequences: The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022’s Farm Debt Relief Causes Farmers Massive Tax Headaches (Deep Dive)

A farmer sits at the edge of his field, holding his head as if tired or stressed out

On August 16, 2022, President Biden signed the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) into law. Section 22006 of the IRA provided $3.1 billion for the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) to provide relief for distressed borrowers under certain Farm Service Agency (FSA) direct and guaranteed loans. On October 18, 2022, USDA provided nearly $800 million in assistance to distressed borrowers to help cure delinquencies and resolve uncollectable farm loan debts. Unintended Consequences of the IRA Payments Farm debt relief is certainly welcome, especially to its recipients. However, when Congress authorized the IRA payments it did not consider that those payments would be counted as income for many recipients, leading to: Two Distressed Borrowers, Similar Problems Consider these two typical borrowers with FSA debts who are in currently not collectible (CNC) status, both of whom benefitted from IRA farm debt relief: Scenario 1: In 2010, Robert defaulted on his FSA-direct loan, which was secured by a lien on his property. When he could not obtain further financing, he could not continue his farming business and the loan went into default. FSA foreclosed, leaving a $100,000 deficiency judgment. Although FSA initially contacted Robert to collect on the debt after the foreclosure, the account was moved into CNC status, where it has remained for 12 years. As of 2022, his past due balance was $150,000, with interest.[1] Scenario 2: Charles has been in default on his FSA-guaranteed loan from a local bank for several years. Charles has continued to farm while working with his bank under forbearance agreements. The debt was moved to the CNC status in 2019. In October of 2022, FSA repaid his entire guaranteed loan to local bank. The payment consisted of principal of $400,000 and interest of $12,000. Now, instead of owing a long-term debt to his bank, with low payments and the option of obtaining a forbearance, he faces a large tax liability (equal to multiple years of payments) due all at once. IRA’s Effects: Increased Taxes While the IRA’s debt relief payments could have many consequences for recipients, for Robert and Charles the primary consequences are increased federal income taxes. In 2022, the IRA program paid Robert’s deficiency, including interest, triggering $150,000 in 2022 taxable income. FSA will send Robert and the IRS a 1099‑G to report this income. Although Robert can deduct the $50,000 in interest paid on his behalf, he is liable for around $24,000 in federal tax, which he cannot pay. If Robert’s state levies an income tax, Robert might also owe state income taxes. When the IRA program paid Charles’s $412,000 debt, he also faced the prospect of significant income taxes, possibly exceeding $100,000. Fortunately, his CPA assisted him in avoiding payment of the income taxes in 2023 for his 2022 income. When FSA notified Charles of the debt repayment to his local bank, Charles immediately turned to his CPA who helped him prepare for this unexpected income surge. The interest is deductible, and won’t increase Charles’s taxable income, but the principal is not deductible. Charles was able to defer collection on some grain sales into 2023, he had Net Operating Losses (NOL) he could use to offset some of the income, and he purchased his 2023 inputs in 2022 to decrease his 2022 Schedule F income and minimize his 2022 self-employment taxes. Current Nonviable and Viable Options Robert and Charles do have options to address their taxes, but all of them have significant downsides. Bankruptcy is not a viable option. Right off the bat, one of the primary tools for dealing with debts is off the table: Any income taxes that Robert or Charles cannot pay would be priority debts in a bankruptcy and not dischargeable in bankruptcy until at least 2026. In that time the IRS and state departments of revenue are likely to file tax liens. There is nothing exempt from an IRS lien, meaning that if the taxpayer had any property with equity, like an exempt homestead, the tax lien would make the tax debt a secured claim in any bankruptcy. While a bankruptcy in several years could discharge the tax debt, it would not eliminate the tax lien, and the IRS or state department of revenue could levy on the property and sell it to collect the tax debt. The insolvency exception to tax liability for debt cancelation is not available. IRC § 108 provides an avenue to avoid the taxes due because of debt cancelation or debt forgiveness. § 108 is commonly referred to as the insolvent taxpayer exception. It allows taxpayers that were insolvent before the debt cancelation to exclude the income from taxation to the extent of their insolvency.[2] Because the debt was paid, not canceled, Robert and Charles cannot reduce their tax liability under IRC § 108. If the debt had been canceled instead of repaid, IRC § 108 would have been available to them to potentially eliminate the income occasioned by the cancelation of the debt. Alas, Congress did not take this route. Installment agreement. It is possible that Robert or Charles could work with the IRS to set up an installment agreement to pay off his tax debt over six years. This could put a significant strain on their finances until the tax debt is repaid. The IRS usually places a tax lien on the taxpayer’s assets until the installment agreement is completed. Moreover, interest and penalties continue to accrue until the debt is paid in full, and the IRS is not required to accept a payment plan. Offer in compromise. Robert and Charles’s best legal remedy may be to hire legal counsel and seek to negotiate an offer in compromise (OIC) with the IRS to lower the amount of tax for which they are liable. The OIC process is complicated and time consuming.[3] It can take many months to finalize, and it includes costly fees. There is no guarantee the IRS will accept an OIC, but IRS states that it generally approves offers in compromise when the amount offered represents the most the IRS

Flaw in Tax Provision of Chapter 12 Fixed

Toolbox full of construction tools

President Trump delivered significant relief to beleaguered family farmers who need to sell farm assets to “right-size” their farm and incur taxes when he signed the Additional Supplemental Appropriations for Disaster Relief Requirements Act, 2017 on October 26, 2017. Tucked in the last six pages of the twenty-six-page bill is the Family Farmer Bankruptcy Clarification Act of 2017. This section was introduced by Senators Chuck Grassley (R, IA) and Al Franken (D, MN) on May 25, 2017 with the stated purpose of reversing the Supreme Court ruling in Hall v. United States.  Four hours after the Supreme Court issued its 5 – 4 ruling in Hall on May 14, 2012, Joseph Peiffer, founder of Ag & Business Legal Strategies, delivered draft corrective Chapter 12 legislation to Senator Grassley’s Senate Judiciary aide. Senator Grassley tenaciously pursued the reversal of Hall by introducing legislation in each of the four Congresses after Hall was issued.  The first three introductions stalled in the Senate Judiciary Committee. This legislation clarifies the inarticulate language chosen by Congress in the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention Consumer Protection Act (BAPCPA) enacted on April 20, 2005 to remedy tax problems of family farmers needing to “right-size” their farms.  The idea to de-prioritize the claims of governments was suggested to Senator Grassley in December of 1998 by Joe Peiffer. Given the inarticulate language choice of Congress, after Hall was decided, family farmers were forced to do their “right-sizing” or asset liquidation in the tax year before filing their Chapter 12 bankruptcies.  For farmers to get the BAPCPA tax relief in Chapter 12, they needed to “right-size” their operations by selling the assets before the end of the year, then filing their Chapter 12 in the following year.  If the farmer decided to sell the assets late in the year, it was often difficult to arrange for the sales to close by the end of the year, so Chapter 12 tax relief was available.  If the farmer learned of the need to sell assets early in the year, they needed to sell the assets and avoid their creditors until the next tax year. Under the new provisions, family farmers will be able to file their Chapter 12 bankruptcies to get creditors off their back, and plan which assets they need to sell to “right-size” their operations, file their plan of reorganization and have the income taxes discharged in their bankruptcy.  This new law should provide the tax relief needed by beleaguered family farmers intended by Congress when BAPCPA was passed in 2005. Joe Peiffer currently has four pending Chapter 12 cases and plans to be a leader in litigating the meaning of the new language fashioned by Congress.  Since the statute is new, it is likely that many of the questions previously litigated regarding its predecessor will have to be re-litigated as Congress has not clarified other ambiguous provisions of the statute. A hearty “thank you” to Senators Grassley and Franken for their unwavering efforts to provide relief for family farmers.  Without support from you, this legislative solution to allow beleaguered family farmers to have a viable chance to reorganize would never have been enacted. Read the full text of the bill here: https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/2266/text

Tough Financial Times in Agriculture and Lending Clauses – Peril for the Unwary

A close-up of crumbling concrete

Overview The farm economy continues to struggle. Of course, certain parts of the country are experiencing more financial trauma than are other parts of the country, but recent years have been particularly difficult in the Corn Belt and Great Plains.  Aggregate U.S. net farm income has dropped by approximately 50 percent from its peak in 2011.  It is estimated to increase slightly in 2017, but it has a long way to go to get back to the 2011 level.  In addition, the value of farmland relative to the value of the crops produced on it has fallen to its lowest point ever.  A dollar of farm real estate has never produced less value in farm production, and real net farm income relative to farm real estate values have not been as low as presently since 1980 to 1983. A deeper dive on farm financial data indicates that after multiple years of declining debt-to-asset ratios, there was an uptick in 2015 and 2016.  Relatedly, default risk remains low, but it also increased in 2015 and 2016.  Also, there has been a decline in the ratio of working capital to assets, and a drop in the repayment capacity of ag loans.  As a financial fitness indicator, repayment capacity is a key.  At the beginning of the farm debt crisis in the early 1980s, it dropped precipitously due to a substantial increase in interest payments and a decline in farm production.  That meant that land values could no longer be supported, and they dropped substantially.  Consequently, many farmers found themselves with collateral value that was lower than the amount borrowed.  Repayment capacity is currently a serious issue that could lead to additional borrowing. While financial conditions may improve a bit in 2017 and on into 2018, working capital may continue to erode in 2017 which could lead to increased debt levels.  That’s because average net farm income will remain at low levels.  This could lead to some agricultural producers and lenders having to make difficult decisions before next spring.  It also places a premium on understanding clause language in lending document and the associated rights and obligations of the parties. Two clauses deserve close attention.  One clause contains “cross-collateralization” language.  “Cross-collateralization” is a term that describes a situation when the collateral for one loan is also used as collateral for another loan. For example, if a farmer takes out multiple loans with the same lender, the security for one loan can be used as cross-collateral for all the loans.  A second clause contains a “co-lessee” provision.  That’s a transaction involving joint and several obligations of multiple parties. Today’s post takes a deeper look at the implications of cross-collateral and co-lessee language in lending documents. My co-author for today’s post is Roger McEowen of Washburn University’s School of Law.  Roger and I have worked together on many presentations through the years on law and taxation.  Cross-Collateralization Language  As noted above, clause language in lending and leasing documents should be carefully reviewed and understood for their implications.  This is particularly true with respect to cross-collateralization language.  For example, the following is an example of such a clause that appears to be common in John Deere security agreements.  Here is how the language of one particular clause reads:   “Security Interest; Missing Information.  You grant us and our affiliates a security interest in the Equipment (and all proceeds thereof) to secure all of your obligations under this Contract and any other obligations which you may have to us or any of our affiliates or assignees at any time and you agree that any security interest you have granted or hereafter grant to us or any of our affiliates shall also secure your obligations under this Contract.  You agree that we may act as agent for our affiliates and our affiliates may as agent for us, in order to perfect and realize on any security interest described above.  Upon receipt of all amounts due and to become due under this Contract, we will release our security interest in the Equipment (but not the security interest for amounts due an affiliate), provided no event of default has occurred and is continuing.  You agree to keep the Equipment free and clear of all liens and encumbrances, except those in favor of us and our affiliates as described above, and to promptly notify us if a lien or encumbrance is placed or threated against the Equipment.  You irrevocably authorize us, at any time, to (a) insert or correct information on this Contract, including your correct legal name, serial numbers and Equipment descriptions; (b) submit notices and proofs of loss for any required insurance; (c) endorse your name on remittances for insurance and Equipment sale or lease proceeds; and (d) file a financing statement(s) which describes either the Equipment or all equipment currently or in the future financed by us.  Notwithstanding any other election you may make, you agree that (1) we can access any information regarding the location, maintenance, operation and condition of the Equipment; (2) you irrevocably authorize anyone in possession of that information to provide all of that information to us upon our request; (3) you will not disable or otherwise interfere with any information gathering or transmission device within or attached to the Equipment; and (4) we may reactivate such device.”   So, what does that clause language mean?  Several points can be made: The clause grants Deere Financial and its affiliates a security interest in the equipment pledged as collateral to secure the obligations owed to it as well as its affiliates. When all obligations (including debt on the equipment purchased under the contract and all other debts for the purchase of equipment that Deere Financial finances) to Deere under the contract are paid, Deere Financial will release its security interest in the equipment. That appears to be straightforward and unsurprising.  However, the release does not release the security interest of the Deere’s affiliates.  This is the cross-collateral provision. The clause also makes Deere Financial the agent of its affiliates,