Rarely Used Ag Bankruptcy Alternatives to Chapter 12

Quick overview Not all farm debt solutions require bankruptcy — there’s also debt restructuring, liquidation, refinancing, and negotiating with creditors. The quick summary of Bankruptcy Chapters: Chapter 12 is an advantageous bankruptcy tool for farmers Chapter 11 is suited to larger ag businesses Chapter 11, Subchapter V is for smaller ag businesses Chapters 7 and 13 are for wage-earners with less debt (typically) than farmers Although the second quarter for the Federal Judiciary ended on June 30, we didn’t get updated numbers on Chapter 12 bankruptcy filings for the full quarter until just recently. Across the country, 115 such bankruptcies were initiated in the second quarter, bringing the January-June total to 201 — approximately 11 percent more than were filed in the first half of 2025. It’s never easy to farm, but current circumstances are testing a lot of producers more than usual with high input costs, elevated land prices, trade obstacles, and a lengthy period of low commodity prices only rising in the past several weeks and falling back down again. Right now the only thing keeping a number of farmers above water are federal government program payments—not sustainable in the long-term. One reason we follow bankruptcy figures is because it’s our job to know this information. But we also use them to show farmers who are facing overwhelming debt and wrestling with the decision about whether to file for bankruptcy to understand if they do so, they are far from alone. Certainly it’s not what any producer aspires to do, but neither is bankruptcy an automatic end to their farm ownership and career as it might have been a few decades ago. Why Chapter 12? Much of that credit goes to the provisions of Chapter 12. Coming out of the Farm Crisis and intended as a dedicated chapter for career farmers and fishers, one of its key provisions is deprioritizing federal tax liability that used to make it difficult if not impossible to confirm a plan of reorganization that satisfied all creditors. In plain language, it means fewer farmers who go through bankruptcy have had to sell off all their land just to pay back taxes. Chapter 12 is far and away the most advantageous federal chapter under which a family farmer can file for bankruptcy, as well as the most-used by farmers by a country mile. It is not, however, the only option in agriculture, and it’s not necessarily the right tool in every case. Schedule a consultation Call Now Other Ag Bankruptcy Options Chapter 11 is another bankruptcy tool available for a fraction of farm filers. It is designed to work best for larger companies that have shareholders, as well as division between ownership and management and labor. It also has some different creditor repayment and reorganization requirements. It’s generally not a good option for an individual family farmer concerning their own land and production. Some ag businesses, however, may not be eligible for Chapter 12 because of their size, organizational structure, or financial circumstances—such as having a certain level of off-farm income, for one. Those farmers’ only option may be a Chapter 11, which is more difficult, time-consuming, and expensive to go through. Also, it does not offer the same tax benefits as Chapter 12. Chapter 11, Subchapter V contains a lower debt limit that is designed for small-business filers; right now that’s a little over $3.4 million. Subchapter V also offers exceptions that benefit smaller businesses, since some of the requirements of Chapter 11 are too onerous for them to reasonably meet in bankruptcy proceedings. It might help a hobby farmer who has too much non-farm income to qualify for Chapter 12. Chapter 13 is intended for individuals who earn more than the designated median income, or wage-earners (as opposed to business owners). It has a very low debt limit, though, and it’s rare for even an individual farmer’s debts to be low enough to qualify for Chapter 13 filing. Chapter 7 is a liquidation bankruptcy, but a farmer can liquidate in a Chapter 12 and receive more favorable tax treatment, so it would only be appropriate if there are no tax concerns. One of Many Tools Ag & Business Legal Strategies will not recommend a farmer file for bankruptcy unless it is their most advantageous option. Our goal is to help clients solve their financial issues, and sometimes that’s accomplished through debt restructuring, liquidation, refinancing, or negotiating with creditors outside of bankruptcy. Just because you consult with a bankruptcy attorney does not mean they will automatically direct you to file for bankruptcy. But keep in mind, neither is it something to be avoided if it offers the best solution; it’s simply another legal tool. And when it comes to using this tool, a farmer’s situation needs to offer compelling reasons for us to recommend filing under a chapter other than Chapter 12. Let’s Discuss Options Call us at 319-363-1641 or click below to email Click Here At Ag & Business Legal Strategies, we want our clients to be honest with themselves and have a solid business plan. Our team will help you create and execute that business plan, and, if necessary, assist you with the legal, tax, and practical aspects of debt restructuring or bankruptcy. Don’t wait for the problems to become insurmountable. Connect with someone you can trust today, not tomorrow, when it may be too late.
Don’t Fear the Creditor

Normally, here is where you might find an analogy comparing troubles in farming with some other life situation. And while that is a useful writing tool, the fact is that an analogy doesn’t always capture the real things we need to explain. And reality is that we are seeing a noticeable uptick in financial distress for farmers this year — not just in our own practice, but in farming overall. Corn and soybean prices are still down significantly from their 10-year high earlier this decade. Meanwhile, input costs for crop growers have not decreased at the same rate. Livestock overall is doing better in 2025, especially beef, but there are producers from these sectors also in the middle of bankruptcy proceedings. Stay on top of financial shifts If you planned to harvest corn at 200 bushels/acre and sell for $5/bushel, but you’re seeing only 180 bpa at $4.20, this is of course going to change your plans for the year. Continuing to hope things will improve as you harvest this month is a wonderful thing, but it will not make up lost income. That’s why you need to update your projections and plans as circumstances change. If projections show revenue will be short, there are decisions to make. Do you have enough in savings to pay creditors such as the bank, a landlord, laborers, suppliers, et cetera? If not, can you tap an additional income stream? Maybe you can sell your harvesting services to other growers in the area. And if you do this in Iowa, be sure to perfect a harvester’s lien with the state no later than 10 days after finishing the work, to ensure you are a priority to be paid timely, even if the farmer for whom you’re harvesting gets crossways with their bank). Or maybe you can pick up extra money hauling grain or livestock, driving a truck, packing silage, assisting with farm chores, or doing other temporary labor? Finding additional sources of income will protect the equity you’ve worked so hard to build over the years. If you’re still struggling to meet your obligations, you may be tempted to finance this short-term debt by rolling it into next year’s operating loan or tapping your land’s equity. But remember, these incur additional interest — like rolling a snowball uphill. At some point that debt snowball grows so large that it will roll back over you. Or, let’s say you’ve learned that you can sell grain for more than what you contracted with another party when you grew it. Or, you’re a month behind on rent and the landlord is pressuring you to pay when you also owe the bank a payment — the bank that holds collateral over your grain. These are both situations in which you may be tempted to seek a short-term solution to pay your most pressing debts, at the risk of legal action and penalties. When your farm production is some creditor’s collateral, you need to be very careful and seek sound legal advice. Don’t underestimate negotiation If you took out a bank loan or operating line of credit, that lender usually takes a security interest in every bushel, bale, hundredweight of milk, or animal you produce, meaning it has first dibs if you do not repay the loan on time. There are exceptions, such as if someone has an aforementioned harvester’s lien for doing work on your land or your landlord perfected a landlord’s lien with the state. We wrote about the pitfalls of selling collateral in a “rob Peter to pay Paul” debt-payoff scenario last fall, but it bears repeating: When your farm product is also collateral, you cannot unilaterally decide how to dispose of it or spend the proceeds. In addition to banks, harvesters, and landlords, certain vendors may also hold statutory liens on your crop or livestock. Here at Ag & Business Legal Strategies, we’ve handled many cases in which a farmer liquidated the collateral they had pledged to others as collateral, then needed our assistance when consequences inevitably happened. One farmer sold his grain under another family member’s name so he could use the proceeds to pay off creditors other than the one that had a security interest in the grain. Now he might not be able to discharge his debt to that creditor in a bankruptcy. Even more seriously, both he and the family member could be indicted for defrauding a financial institution — a federal felony — and possibly serve time in a federal penitentiary. In another case, the farmer sealed grain with the government’s Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC). Instead of delivering that grain to an elevator and repaying the sealed loan, he sold it elsewhere to pay bills. Not only did he have to repay the CCC, he also paid a fine and was barred from applying for another CCC sealed grain loan for two years. Yet another farmer created a limited liability corporation to sell his grain and tried to argue since that corporation didn’t owe any debts, it was free to sell the products. In all three of these cases, the collateral holders demanded their share; in fact, even after filing for bankruptcy, the third farmer will owe a six-figure debt that the bankruptcy court cannot discharge. Prepare, don’t react Our attorneys are certainly capable of providing representation for these kinds of cases — but we would rather help producers on the front end avoid fines, judgments, and possibly even jail time. If it seems to be difficult to pay your bank or other creditors in full this season, Ag & Business Legal Strategies can assist in reviewing your options and finding the best solution that does not risk jail time or non-discharged debts if a bankruptcy is necessary. If you have a close relationship with your bank and know you’ll be receiving later income — for example, crop-loss insurance — and you can convince your loan officer to wait, that’s great! If not, we can reach out to your
Farm Balance Sheets

At Ag & Business Legal Strategies, we want our clients to be honest with themselves and have a solid business plan. Our attorneys and financial strategist will help you create and execute that business plan, and, if necessary, assist you with the legal, tax, and practical aspects of debt restructuring or bankruptcy. Don’t wait for the problems to become insurmountable. Connect with someone you can trust today, not tomorrow.
What Every Bankruptcy Lawyer Must Know About Chapter 12

Shareholder Joe Peiffer and associate Austin Peiffer recently co-authored an article on chapter 12 bankruptcy with Vermont bankruptcy trustee Jan Sensenich. It was published in the May 2021 edition of the American Bankruptcy Institute‘s ABI Journal. **As of April 1, 2022, the chapter 12 bankruptcy debt limit was raised to $11,097,350.
Joe Peiffer on The Big Show re: Dean Foods

Joe Peiffer had the opportunity to chat with Andy Petersen of WHO’s The Big Show regarding the Dean Foods preference recovery efforts. The host aired the interview in two parts, on December 7, 2020 and December 8, 2020. The audio is embedded below and also transcribed: December 7, 2020 Dean Foods Interview Andy Petersen: Well, some concerning letters showing up to people who sold milk to Dean Foods before they declared bankruptcy, which was maybe about a year ago or so. You’ll get more into that here, and what your options are. There are options, it sounds like, but not responding is not one of them, if I can throw some more negatives in there for you. Joe Peiffer is here. He’s the founder of Ag and Business Legal Strategies in Cedar Rapids, and a good buddy of The Big Show and one of our legal experts that we turn to in times like this. And, Joe, what’s going on? Joe Peiffer: Well, what’s going on is what happens in a lot of bankruptcies: literally, that at some point in the case, somebody will make a demand to recover what are known as preferences. A preference is a payment that’s been made to a creditor within 90 days of filing a bankruptcy. The idea here, and when Congress set the Bankruptcy Code back in 1978, was to say, well, gee, if people got paid within 90 days, they might have gotten more than their fair share. So, they give the bankruptcy the power to chase those preferences, and pull the money back into the bankruptcy estate and to share it with everybody. It sort of reminds me of Robin Hood, if you will. Nonetheless, preferences have been very frustrating for many, many years. People do not like them. They say, “I got paid fair and square. Why do I have to give the money back?” Part of the idea here is to equalize distribution among different groups of creditors. But there are defenses, and the Dean Foods letters remind me of what happened in the VeraSun ethanol bankruptcy in Delaware back in 2010. In that case, lawyers from Delaware and in New York sent letters out to thousands of farmers all across the Midwest, demanding that any payments that cleared their bank within 90 days of filing bankruptcy be returned. That’s what appears to be happening in the Dean Foods bankruptcies. Dean Foods and 43 affiliates filed a bankruptcy in Houston, Texas, on November 12th, 2019. Now demands are being put out by a law firm out of Saint Paul, Minnesota, demanding money, all the payments within 90 days. Not just the dairy farmers, but other creditors, too. We’re going to focus on the defenses the dairy farmers have, and they’ll be similar to some others. But dairy farmers typically have what I think is going to be a very strong defense, called “ordinary course of business”, or course of dealing. Provided that Dean Foods was paying them a couple of times a month, and either by check or by EFT … If that was happening, deliver milk, get paid; deliver milk, get paid; deliver milk, get paid, that’s an ordinary course of business defense. It should be golden. But what these letters say is, you’ve got a given period of time to pay us a certain amount of money, and I think it’s approximately 25% of the amount, or they’re going to sue the farmer. They’re going to sue the farmer in bankruptcy court in Houston, Texas. Now, I don’t know, but I think most of the Midwestern farmers don’t have bankruptcy lawyers on tap in Houston, Texas. For the most part, they’d just as soon never touch a bankruptcy lawyer’s office, but this is one of those times where you might need to talk with a bankruptcy expert to help you migrate and respond to these letters. If you do not respond, you’re going to be sued. If you do respond, and you provide the documentation to prove a defense, chances are they won’t do anything. But most of my farm clients aren’t used to assembling documentation in a fashion that a bankruptcy lawyer is used to looking at. So, in order to help people, next week on December 9th I’m going to hold a free Zoom meeting. Anybody that wants to jump in can jump in, and we’ll talk about it. And if people can’t make it on the 9th, we’ll have a follow-up meeting on the 14th. They’ll both be at one o’clock. The key thing you want to do: get your information, showing the payments you got and the deliveries of milk when they happened. If they happened like when my father was dairying back in the ’70’s, deliver milk, get paid; deliver milk, get paid, I see no way that the Dean Foods people can possibly win. If they were not paying on time, and they were delinquent in paying you, that’s a different story. Then we have to see if there are other defenses that can be used. AP: This is something that, when you and I talked earlier, you compared it, I believe, to extortion. JP: Correct. It reminds me of extortion, because they’re threatening to sue you in a court, a long ways away, and saying, “If you’ll pay me something, we won’t sue you.” In my mind, if you have no right to something, to threaten to do something which you shouldn’t do in the first place because you haven’t done your homework, is extortion. Or, blackmail is another term that comes to mind. This may be a situation where paying a few bucks to somebody to help you organize your answer beats the heck out of paying them the price they want to say for freedom. AP: Joe Peiffer, there. He is the founder of Ag and Business Legal Strategies in Cedar Rapids, a good friend of the Big Show. You can read more on this subject. He
ABLS Saves Debtor Thousands, Receives Judge’s Compliments

Recently shareholder Joe Peiffer and associate Austin Peiffer went toe-to-toe with attorneys representing Farm Credit over that creditor’s exorbitant fee demand. While secured creditors often have the right to make the debtor pay their attorney fees, those fees must be reasonable, and in this case they weren’t. Judge Collins agreed, and by objecting to Farm Credit’s fees ABLS’s client saved over $65,000. Tons of Information Working on a tight deadline, the ABLS team analyzed hundreds of pages of time entries filed by Farm Credit’s attorneys. This analysis revealed numerous duplicate billings and, indeed, billing for things that were, in fact, unnecessary. One unique aspect of this case is that the debtor had five loans with Farm Credit. Farm Credit required that its attorneys bill each loan individually, generating five different sets of invoices for this work. This made the analysis even more tricky. Sometimes the exact same entry would appear on multiple bills. In order to ascertain the actual amount of time spent, the Judge and his team needed to review all five sets of invoices and compare them. In this comparison, they often found duplicates. A High Standard Judge Collins was complementary of ABLS’s approach to billing and fees: “The Court specifically notes that Debtor’s counsel, and his firm’s billing practices are very well known to the Court. The Court has reviewed and approved numerous fee applications from Debtor’s counsel–in both large and small cases. The Court has previously recognized that Debtor’s counsel is incredibly thorough, detail-oriented, and well-prepared. This has earned Debtor’s counsel a stellar reputation in Chapter 12 cases, but that thorough approach pushes up the cost of his services.” Judge Collins also noted that Farm Credit’s counsel and the law firm, “also have an excellent reputation for excellence in this type of work.” This makes evident His Honor’s respect for the members of the bar that practice in front of him. Furthermore, this opinion illustrates the high standard that he requires in this district. You can read the whole opinion here: Kurtenbach (Debtor) Opinion. The opinion also caught the attention of columnist Bill Rochelle. He wrote about the opinion in his daily blog “Rochelle’s Daily Wire” on the ABI website (ABI membership required to bypass paywall). Ag & Business Legal Strategies is a law firm that works strenuously to defend its clients’ interests. Operating often in the debtor-creditor sphere, ABLS has positioned its professionals uniquely to understand their clients’ needs and work to obtain the desired results.
Thirty-Three Years of Asking, “Are We There Yet?”

The Commercial Law League of America recently published Joe Peiffer’s article “Thirty-Three Years of Asking “Are We There Yet?”” as one of the title articles in the summer edition of their publication, Commercial Law World. Click the image below to read the article. **As of April 1, 2022 the chapter 12 bankruptcy debt limit has increased to $11,097,350.
Chapter 12 Debt Limit on the Big Show

Joseph Peiffer chats with Doug Cooper about Chapter 12 and raising its debt limit on the Big Show The audio from this conversation is below, as well as the transcript. Doug Cooper:I have been spending some time with Joe Peiffer. He is a bankruptcy lawyer with Ag & Business Legal Strategies, and he has been talking about the need to extend the debt limit in Chapter 12 bankruptcy. Joe, give us an update. Joe Peiffer:Yesterday the Senate passed H.R.2336, the Family Farmer Relief Act of 2019. That act increases the debt limit for Chapter 12 to $10 million.* It’ll be effective when President Trump signs the bill. It passed the house a week ago Thursday. It passed the Senate yesterday. The process of getting it passed has been a bit tortured, as most things are in Washington these days. Because we have divided Congress and there’s a lot of polarization, it’s been difficult to get anything through. Farm Bill made it to the Senate this past Monday, and lots of people contacted their senators, said we support this Family Farmer Relief Act, which would increased the debt limit, and they also asked their senators to contact Senator Durbin and tell him to remove his hold. Joe Peiffer:As of Wednesday, the status was that Durbin had released his holds on three bills that had been initiated by Democrats in the house. The only one he hadn’t released it on was a small business reorganization act. That was the only bill that was started by a Republican in the House. The Senate Republicans, since they’re in the majority said, “No, we’re not going to let you have three bills started by Democrats in the House if we don’t get something back in return.” The package went through late yesterday afternoon, about three o’clock is when I got the call that it had just passed the Senate. Senator Durbin removed his hold on the Small Business Bankruptcy Reorganization Act. Then it, along with the Family Farmer Relief Act, the Haven Act, and the National Guard and Reservist Debt Relief Extension Act all passed basically the same time. Now all four of those bills will head to the President. The Family Farmer Relief Act will be effective when President Trump signs it. The expectation is high that the President will sign all four of these bills. Doug Cooper:Joe, I realize that there are some farmers out there that are possibly facing bankruptcy. Will this encourage them to move forward now that Chapter 12 debt limit has moved from $4-plus million to $10 million? Joe Peiffer:The current debt limit’s $4.4 million, and the new one will be $10 million. Will it encourage more? I don’t think it’s going to encourage, but it will allow. And when I say that, I have never found a client coming in saying, “I really want to file bankruptcy.” They come in to me, and the reality of the situation is they’ll file if there’s no better alternative. In many instances, they’ve done many things trying to stave off bankruptcy. They have taken the money out of their retirement plans, they’ve borrowed on everything they’ve got, they’ve sold a lot of things they perhaps shouldn’t have sold trying to stay out of bankruptcy, because nobody likes the thought of the taint of bankruptcy. They’d rather not file bankruptcy, because that to them is an admission of failure. “I couldn’t make my business run.” I doubt it will encourage more, but it will allow them another tool if they need it. Joe Peiffer:The other thing it will do, as was set out in a 1993 study by Dr. Harlan, Iowa State, was that the availability of Chapter 12 allowed banks and farmers to negotiate against the backdrop of some certainty as to what would probably happen if a bankruptcy were filed. And in many instances, with the backdrop of how the case would come out if a bankruptcy were filed, they were able to make a deal that didn’t require bankruptcy, and it helped a great deal doing that. Doug Cooper:Let me ask that a little bit differently, Joe. Does this give farmers more leverage with their financial institutions? Joe Peiffer:If they were over the current $4.4 million limit, yes, it will give them some more leverage, because reorganization within a Chapter 11 for a farmer is virtually impossible. That’s why Chapter 12 was set up in 1986. So by increasing the debt limit to $10 million, we now have many more farmers that can use the power of Chapter 12 to restructure their indebtedness within bankruptcy. And if they need to, they can also, if they have to liquidate assets, within Chapter 12, there is an extremely powerful tax provision that allows that tax to be treated as an unsecured claim. This is what makes Chapter 12 the most powerful chapter of bankruptcy in the bankruptcy code. Doug Cooper:Joe, are your phone’s still ringing? Are farmers calling in and at least asking questions, trying to figure out what direction they should go in dealing with their financial institutions? Joe Peiffer:We have a lot of questions about people saying, “What can we do?” Candidly, I’m hopeful that people will consider their options earlier rather than later. The farmer should be proactive and looking for alternatives before the banker says, “I won’t loan you another dime.” If the farmer says, “I’ve been losing money, and Mr. Banker here’s what I plan to do to try to change things, and let’s change the structuring of our debt,” that will be welcomed by the banker, because you’re now addressing the situation. If you’re not addressing the situation, and you assume that everything’s going to be the same, and you can always assume the bank will loan you money, that’s a bad assumption. It’s far better that the farmer take it head on, get the help he needs management-wise so that they can move forward and hopefully negotiate out without the need for a
Joe Peiffer Discusses Cash Flows on the Big Show

Doug Cooper: Joe Peiffer is a bankruptcy lawyer with Ag & Business Legal Strategies in Cedar Rapids and Joe, we’ve been talking about a number of things and a couple of things slipped through last congress and didn’t get done. One of those was the debt increase on Chapter 12. What’s the latest? Joe Peiffer: Well, Chapter 12, we’ve been talking about Chapter 12 for a long time and the debt limit in Chapter 12. And the debt limit raised a little bit the first of April. The current debt limit for Chapter is $4,411,400. Strange number because it’s only indexed for inflation. Back from 1986 when it was started at $1,500,000 till now. The last congress, Senator Grassley and Senator Klobuchar from Minnesota introduced a bill called the Family Farmer Relief Act of 2018, that was in December, it didn’t go anywhere. On March 27th of this year they introduced the Family Farmer Relief Act of 2019, S897 and it now has 11 co-sponsors and a companion bill has been introduced in the House, HR2336. HR2336 and S897 would increase the debt limit for Chapter 12 to $10,000,000 and continue the indexing. I recently heard something on US Farm Report and John Phipps was decrying increasing the debt limit for Chapter 12, saying it doesn’t provide a fresh start and indicating that perhaps whenever a creditor is listed in a bankruptcy, be it a fertilizer supplier or feed supplier, that the price for that goes up for everyone else. Well, there probably is a situation where people do build in a loss, an allowance for bad debt or loss in their cash flows for these companies, however it doesn’t matter whether it’s a Chapter 12 bankruptcy or a Chapter 7 bankruptcy that’s filed, if the debt’s uncollectible, it’s uncollectible and that really is a hollow reason not to allow Chapter 12 to increase the debt limit so that farmers can use Chapter 12 to get a fresh start, including not having the staggering tax bill that many of them are going to have. It seems right now that we have the never ending trade war and with that trade war going on perhaps farmers are becoming additional collateral damage. I understand the President seeking to ease those losses, but at the same time as he says he’s going to buy product, are we really getting what we need? I don’t know the answer to that, but I do know that a lot of my clients that are in deep trouble will become collateral damage and will need Chapter 12 in order to start over, even if that means a liquidation. Because Chapter 12 now provides the strongest chapter bankruptcy and allows them to start over without a huge tax bill that they would have otherwise. DC: Joe, you mentioned collateral damage that farmers could be caught in, what are you hearing from farmers, their concerns, their stress level right now? JP: What I’m hearing is this, we’re still trying to get people financing to get in the field yet this year. That’s normally something we’ve got lined up by the first of March or the 15th of March, at the latest. Not this year. This year we’re still getting calls from people that do not have financing to go to the filed. This is the latest I’ve had in 37 years of practice, of people having trouble getting financing. DC: Joe, if you haven’t secured financing at this point, isn’t it too late? JP: The likelihood of getting financing now is very low. We have a couple of companies that I would call second tier lenders that are out there that are making some loans, but they’re very proud of their money, it’s very expensive to get it and the question is are you better off letting somebody else rent the land and letting it go than you are trying to farm it? Which way will you lose less, becomes an operative question for a lot of my clients right now. DC: Joe, there are reports that the stress level of farmers has increased for a number of reasons. What’s your best advice? What should they do at this point? JP: Farmers that are under the stress, they’ve planted, they’re wondering what’s going to happen. First off, take care of your mental health. Get the exercise you need, that helps with mental health. Get counseling if you need it. Be big enough to admit you need help. You can’t do it alone. In addition, keep those pencils and computers working, look at your cash flow at all times, especially when you get back in around the first of July or so, you’ve got the final spraying done, look at everything again. See where you are compared to the budget you set forth, move forward and see what changes you need to given the new reality of what you expect your yields to be and what you expect your marketing to be. Be very proactive. You need to be proactive, not reactive. Hopefully, if you need to make adjustments you can go into your bank and say, “Hey, I need to make some adjustments. Here are the adjustments I plan to make. Are you with me?” And work with your banker on this, so that you can move forward and keep an operation together. These are very stressful times and those who do nothing will be in much worse shape than those who are proactive and looking for alternatives. DC: Joe Peiffer, a bankruptcy lawyer with Ag & Business Legal Strategies in Cedar Rapids. I’m Doug Cooper on the Big Show.
Crisis Resources

Farming is good honest work, but it can be stressful and bad situations can feel overwhelming. Crisis may be as close as next harvest, or a bank not renewing the crop note. If you’re feeling like you don’t have what it takes to keep going, ask for help; there are resources available to people just like you. You don’t have to deal with the crisis on your own. Here are some resources that may be helpful: Iowa Concern Hotline: 1-800-447-1985 Iowa Concern started in 1985 as a toll-free number serving the agricultural community. Today, Iowa Concern serves urban and rural Iowa. https://www.extension.iastate.edu/iowaconcern/ Availability: 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Mobile Crisis Outreach: Call, or text, 1-855-800-1239. Availability to call, or text: 24 hours a day, 7 days a week Mobile Crisis Outreach serves East Central Iowa and it is offered free of charge. You can also talk with Mobile Crisis Outreach online, https://foundation2.org/mobile-crisis-outreach/. National Suicide Prevention Lifeline: 988 or 1-800-273-8255. The National Suicide Prevention Lifeline provides free, confidential emotional support for people in suicidal, or emotional distress. https://suicidepreventionlifeline.org/. Availability: 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. If you know of other resources that we should list here, please drop us a line using the contact form here: https://www.ablsonline.com/contact/
Venue Reform & Effects for Farmers

From February 25-27 Joe Peiffer and Mark Kuhn (one of the farmers affected by the VeraSun bankruptcy in Delaware) were in Washington DC for the Commercial Law League of America‘s Hill Day to talk with lawmakers about bankruptcy venue reform. While they were there they spoke with Doug Cooper on The Big Show about their efforts. Here are the interviews: Doug’s interview with Joe: Doug Cooper: Joe Peiffer is an agricultural lawyer from Cedar Rapids. He is with Ag & Business Legal Strategies, and he has been working on a potential bill called the Bankruptcy Venue Reform Act of 2018. I caught up with him in the nation’s capital. Joe Peiffer: Doug, I’m out in Washington, D.C. and I’m out here with the Commercial Law League of America, and we are having Hill Day. The prime issue that I’m here to work on behalf of farmers in general is the Bankruptcy Venue Reform Act of 2018. DC: And that is what? JP: The Bankruptcy Venue Reform Act is S.2282. It was introduced on January 8 by Senator Cornyn, a Republican from Texas, and Senator Warren, a Democrat from Massachusetts, and it will reform where bankruptcies can be filed. Currently, bankruptcies can be filed wherever a company is organized or wherever an affiliate, which is another company in the same group of companies, may file a bankruptcy, or wherever significant assets of a company are located. That’s been a problem for Iowa farmers and farmers in the Midwest in general, as illustrated by the VeraSun bankruptcy in 2008. DC: Remind us what happened there. JP: In VeraSun, the bankruptcy was filed on October 31, 2008 in Delaware. VeraSun was the world’s largest producer of ethanol at the time, had 23 plants in 6 states, and filed bankruptcy in Delaware. I checked: Delaware had no ethanol plants and still has no ethanol plants. The farmers had contracted to sell grain to VeraSun, and the market had dropped out and VeraSun had agreed to pay in many instances $7 or upwards of $8/bushel for grain, and it had not protected itself on the other side in the options market. It ran out of cash, so all the sudden it’s got all these contracts due, it files bankruptcy so it has the right to terminate those contracts, and by terminating, the farmer would be free to sell their grain wherever. Unfortunately, they don’t have to assume or reject those contracts until after a plan is confirmed. That could be many months later. In 2008, you’ll probably recall that in the fall, we had grain in the neighborhood of $5/bushel and it was dropping. The farmers were faced with a terrible problem. If they sold their grain to minimize their loss, that was good. They could at least get $5/bushel for their corn, but their concern was what if the market turns and it goes back to $7? So the contract was at $7 and they sold for $5, now that covered their loss, but then if it goes back to $7, VeraSun could’ve required them to cover the difference between what they sold it for and what the market had returned to on the contract. For example, if the farmer who had a contract to sell with VeraSun for $7 and ended up selling at $5 after the bankruptcy, and then it went back to $7, he could have to pay $2/bushel, which means he effectively got $3/bushel for his corn. DC: What kind of reaction have you received in Washington, D.C., and what is the current status of this bill? JP: I’ll start with the current status. The current status of the bill is that it’s in the Senate Judiciary Committee. We are building support, and in fact, I just came out of a meeting with the National Association of Attorneys General, who happen to be having their annual convention here. And we’re hopeful that that group will support it. We’re getting support from many different factors, or many different groups, the Iowa Bankers Association signed on right away, and what we’re hoping to do is to keep building that support. One of the things you need to think about right now is that Ted Cruz is railing against renewable fuel standards. He’s pointing out the Pennsylvania Energy Company bankruptcy, which is a refinery that filed bankruptcy in Delaware recently, saying the employees there are in trouble because of the renewable fuel standards, which is part of the basis of the ethanol plant. If he’s successful, there could be ethanol plant bankruptcies coming up, and under the current bankruptcy laws, I can virtually guarantee they’re going to be filed in either the Southern District of New York or Delaware. If we don’t want that to happen, now’s the time to act. People out here are generally receptive to the idea, with the exception of folk from Delaware or New York, who are getting the bulk of the cases. I was out here in 2008 with Mark Kuhn, and we went to Delaware in the VeraSun bankruptcy, and Mark pointed out he was the only one in the room with blue jeans on. Everybody else had blue suits on. And we could not get the judge to agree that VeraSun should be required to assume or reject the contracts quickly. In fact, all of the farmers that had VeraSun contracts were invited to come to Delaware to seek relief. How many farmers A) can afford to make it to Delaware, B) can afford to hire Delaware counsel, and C) should have to go that far to protect their interests? DC: Joe, it’s early, but what’s your gut feeling? JP: Gut feeling is momentum is building, but it’s a marathon. It’s not a sprint, and we need the support of people who are affected. Not just farmers – it’s other businesspeople that dealt with these companies as well. Because the next one that happens will affect anybody that’s doing business with the companies. DC:
Joseph Peiffer on the Big Show Talking Venue Reform (Part 2)

Joseph Peiffer joined Doug Cooper on the Big Show again last week to talk about the new Bankruptcy Venue Reform Act of 2018 that was recently introduced in Congress. Here’s part 2 of their conversation from January 18, 2018. Doug Cooper: Yesterday I visited with Joe Peiffer, a bankruptcy lawyer with Ag & Business Legal Strategies. He has been working on a bill, the Bankruptcy Venue Reform Act of 2017, that would reduce the number of miles you would have to travel to argue your case if a corporation or business declares bankruptcy. Joe Peiffer: In many instances, they’ll make a deal and pay something for certainty to make sure they’ve gotten rid of the claim of the creditor, despite the fact that they may have good defenses. The cost of hiring Delaware counsel is high, and you always have the uncertainty. Conversely, if you were in the Midwest, and that’s where the case is filed, the cost of defending yourself is far less. DC: Joe, let’s do a little Civics 101 right now. What are some of the hurdles the bill has to go through before it becomes law? JP: Okay. At the current time, the bill has been introduced and was assigned to the Senate Judiciary Committee. The Senate cannot act on it until it comes out of the Judiciary Committee. So at the current time we’re seeking to get lots of senators of both parties to say this is a good bill. If that occurs, then the Judiciary Committee could agree to suspend regular order and report the bill out of committee. Once a bill’s out of committee, it could be added to any other bill and potentially get wings and go through the Senate. Once it’s through the Senate, then it will go to the House. Assuming it ends up being part of a bill that’s identical in both the House and Senate versions, and it’s passed, then it will go on to the President. Something else that could happen in here is that the House could introduce companion legislation through its Judiciary Committee. I believe it’ll be a lot easier to get this bill passed through the House because you don’t have to worry about getting 60 votes, and if that were to happen, then the Senate could take it up, because it had been passed by the House. So we’ve got several ways of getting to go in this. Right now, it’s in the Senate Judiciary Committee. DC: Seems to me that the chair of the Senate’s Judiciary Committee, Chuck Grassley, would have interest in this. JP: I won’t get to talk to him this week. I am talking – I have spoken with his Judiciary staff person, Brad Watts, and he is assigned to handle bankruptcy matters for Senator Grassley. And he is watching this carefully. I’ll be meeting with Senator Grassley’s staffer, Mr. Watts, I believe on Friday. I happen to be going to D.C. for another matter, so I’ll be working the Hill while I’m there. If we can get both of our senators and all of our representatives to be on board, to press this legislation, which is, I believe, good for not only Iowa farmers, but all of Iowa’s citizens by virtue of making certain that if any bankruptcies are filed that involve us with Iowa-based companies or Midwest based companies, that the bankruptcies are filed close to home. DC: What’s your gut feeling at this point? JP: My gut feeling is that if the grassroots gets to work on this thing and supports it, it could become reality. If the grassroots doesn’t get out there and keep pushing their senators and representatives, it could die in the Senate Judiciary Committee. For example, we talked about Chapter 12 bankruptcy changes last fall. It took five and a half years after the Supreme Court handed down a case decision that went against the family farmer for the bill to finally get passed and enacted as legislation. It has taken – I’ve been on the Commercial Law League of America Bankruptcy Venue Reform Committee for over five years. This is the first time that we’ve gotten legislation introduced. That’s a big step, but we need a big push and a lot of help from a lot of people calling their senators and representatives, telling them to support this if we’re going to get it across the finish line. DC: Any final thoughts, Joe? JP: Well, the other thought would be if you support this legislation, be active. If your senator or representative doesn’t call you back or give you a response, call them again. E-mail them again. If you become the squeaky wheel, they recognize who has the power at the ballot box, and that’s the citizens. It’s important for the citizens of the states to be heard because the other side is very well funded, but the other side that has a lot of lobbyists going, they don’t get to vote here. The voters can speak loud. If the voters speak, it’ll outweigh the money that may be offered to them by the other side. DC: Joe Peiffer is a bankruptcy attorney with Ag & Business Legal Strategies in Cedar Rapids, Iowa. I’m Doug Cooper on the Big Show.
Joseph Peiffer on the Big Show Talking Venue Reform (Part 1)

Joseph Peiffer joined Doug Cooper on the Big Show again last week to talk about the new Bankruptcy Venue Reform Act of 2018 that was recently introduced in Congress. Here’s part 1 of their conversation from January 17, 2018. Doug Cooper: Joe Peiffer with Ag & Business Legal Strategies in Cedar Rapids, Iowa is a bankruptcy lawyer and he says the first step in solving some bankruptcy venue issues has been introduced in Congress. Joe Peiffer: The Bankruptcy Venue Reform Act of 2018 was introduced on Monday, January 8, 2018, by Republican Senator John Cornyn and Democratic Senator Elizabeth Warren. It may sound like the strangest of bedfellows with Republican Cornyn and Democrat Warren; however, the best chance of getting anything done in Congress right now is to have bipartisan support. Senator Cornyn is a ranking member of the Senate Judiciary Committee. Senator Warren is a rising Democratic star. Getting them to work together is very good for this legislation. We spoke about this legislation before Christmas, since we thought it would be introduced then, and it ended up being introduced shortly after Congress returned from its Christmas break. DC: Did they make any changes to it, Joe? JP: They have made only cosmetic changes. The substance of the bill is exactly like we were talking about back in December, but since it’s been filed we’ve had some really interesting developments. The people from the State of Delaware are incensed that we would do this, or have this bill introduced, and they say that our argument that having bankruptcies filed either where the headquarters of the company is or where the principal assets of the company are would promote better access to justice, they claim is false. They say that the judges in the rest of the United States are not prepared or equipped to handle large bankruptcy cases. I find that argument to be a condescending slap in the face of every bankruptcy judge that isn’t in the State of Delaware or the Southern District of New York. All of the bankruptcy judges before whom I have appeared are smart people who have worked hard to get to where they’re at and who would quickly learn what needs to be done in a larger case. DC: Do you think you’ve got enough votes? JP: Well, at this point we’re trying to garner more votes. It’s much easier to get people to support a concept or a bill after the bill has been introduced. Before it’s introduced, we’re talking about a concept, this is our idea of what we’d like to do. Now we have concrete language that folks can look at and see exactly what’s being proposed and why it’s being proposed. We’re building support around the country. It is important, if people are interested in having bankruptcies of companies be filed where the assets are or where the headquarters are, that they let their congressmen know about it, let their senators know, ask their congressmen to support this legislation to potentially introduce it in the House and the senators to co-sponsor it. It’s going to be a long, hard slog because the folks on the other side are very well armed. From 2003 to 2016, the State of Delaware ended up getting 735 Chapter 11 bankruptcies of companies that had no effective business ties to the State of Delaware. Those are companies that might have been from California, from Iowa, from Washington, even from Alaska or Hawaii. I was looking at a case called Lilly Robotics. It was filed in late February of last year. Of the 30 largest creditors, 20 were from the State of California, yet it was filed in Delaware. When cases are filed in Delaware or the Southern District of New York, retirees have to seek to go to New York or Delaware to find out what the Court may do to their retirement benefits. Farmers, like the farmers in VeraSun, could have to go to Delaware to see if they can get their contracts released so they can sell their grain. The involuntary creditors, like the person that extends some credit to a company, like the guy on Main Street that perhaps is selling to the company and didn’t get paid on time could be hauled off to the court in Delaware or New York on a preference theory saying that well, you got paid a little late and the payment you received within 90 days of filing the bankruptcy is a preference. That becomes an economic burden and hardship for the people that are drug halfway or all the way across the country to defend themselves, and in many instances they’ll make a deal and pay something for certain, either to make sure they’ve gotten rid of the claim with the creditor despite the fact that they may have good defenses. DC: Joe Peiffer with Ag & Business Legal Strategies in Cedar Rapids is a bankruptcy lawyer. I’m Doug Cooper on the Big Show.
Doug Cooper and Joe Peiffer on Venue Reform

Doug Cooper recently visited with Joe on the Big Show regarding Bankruptcy Venue Reform. Part 1 (Aired December 18, 2017): Doug Cooper: I’m going to visit today with Joe Peiffer, he’s a lawyer with Ag & Business Legal Strategies, and he says this week he is hoping to get a bill on the floor of Congress called the Bankruptcy Venue Reform that he says will benefit farmers, employees, and creditors of companies doing business in Iowa by limiting the choice of place where bankruptcies can be filed. Joe, give us some background on this. Why is it needed? Joe Peiffer: There’s a move afoot in Congress, and I’ve been working with a group of attorneys and Congressmen from all over the country to change where bankruptcies can be filed. I suspect that there are a lot of the listeners who remember the VeraSun ethanol plant bankruptcy that was filed in 2008. VeraSun had 26 ethanol plants in six midwestern states. Yet, it filed its bankruptcy in Wilmington, Delaware. DC: What difference does that make, and why Delaware? JP: It filed there because it had one of its affiliates, which is like a brother or sister corporation, that was incorporated in Delaware. Then, it could file every other affiliated business in Delaware because it had filed one there. It could properly file, and you can at this time, properly file a bankruptcy where a company is organized, which is where you incorporate. And then, any other brother or sister company, or parent or subsidiary, can follow whoever filed first. In VeraSun, every plant had a separate company. So, because every plant had a separate company, all they needed to do was have one that was organized in Delaware and then every other one could follow it to Delaware. Now, that affected an awful lot of farmers in the Midwest. I put together a short video because I had the privilege of representing over 100 farmers in the VeraSun bankruptcy. In VeraSun, the farmers had contracted to sell grain at very high prices. Unfortunately, the market turned. After the market turned and VeraSun hadn’t properly hedged its supply, it ended up in a cash crunch so it filed a Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Well, in that bankruptcy, all of the contracts that were out there with the farmers to supply grain were still enforceable by VeraSun, even though most of them were out of the money. You might have a contract for $7.00 corn and corn was $5.50. Common sense tells that the ethanol plant isn’t going to agree to pay you $7.00 when the going price is $5.50. The company did not have to reject your contract or let you out of it until it finished its bankruptcy plan. You don’t have to file a Chapter 11 bankruptcy plan for up to 120 days, sometimes that’s extended. So now all of the sudden, we’ve got farmers with contracts out there that VeraSun cannot be forced to honor but then if the price comes back and VeraSun’s in the money, VeraSun could make the farmer honor it—one sided as heck. So the farmers that I represented hired me to go out to Delaware with a farmer, Mark Kuhn, and we went out to seek, ask the judge whether we could speed up the process of VeraSun agreeing to accept or reject these contracts. So we wanted to do it on a plant-by-plant basis, so that we look at the Charles City plant, or we’d look at the plants up in Minnesota, on a plant-by-plant basis and have all the farmers that had contracts there ask the judge at one time to set up a mechanism to make them assume or reject the contract. The judge wasn’t interested. The judge said that every farmer could come out to Delaware and seek his assistance. Well, to me, it becomes a question of what’s the access to justice, because now you’ve got all of the people that had done business with the ethanol plants are out here in Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska, the Dakotas, I can’t think, there were a couple in Michigan that were being called out to Delaware. When you go to Delaware, I’m not admitted in Delaware, so in order for me to appear in Delaware, I had to hire a lawyer to review everything I was doing and then to be in court with me to introduce me to the judge and ask the judge for permission to allow me to talk. You know, Delaware is a long way from Charles City, Iowa, so what we’ve been doing is working to see if there’s a way to make this more fair and to provide people with better access to the courts. And so what we’ve come upon is some language in a bill that we believe is going to be introduced Wednesday. It’s called the Bankruptcy Venue Reform Act of 2017. So, what I am asking people to do, then I’m going to ask farmers who believe like I do that it’s important that bankruptcy be filed close to where the creditors are and close to where the companies are doing business to support this. Call your senator. Ask your senator to support the bill and to co-sponsor it. Call your representative. Let them know that this bill’s coming, that you’re supporting it, that you want them to support it, and hopefully Congress will actually work quickly and do something. DC: Joe, it’s the holiday season, the tax bill is being debated, what are the odds do you think, it could get done before Christmas or before the end of the year? JP: I’m told there is an outside chance that it could get attached to the budget bill next week. I’m a realist, it probably won’t get done. But if we provide Congress with a lot of people calling in, emailing them, or even writing, my preference is that you, instead of write, that you email or call and tell them
Thirty Years of Asking

Joe Peiffer recently wrote an article for the American Bankruptcy Institute Journal entitled Thirty Years of Asking, “Are We There Yet?”: Congress Rights a Taxing Wrong in Chapter 12. Click the thumbnail below to read the entire article:
How Recently Enacted Amendment to Clarify Chapter 12 Will Help Struggling Farmers – Ep. 208

Joe Peiffer recently chatted with Sam Gerdano of the American Bankruptcy Institute regarding the changes in Chapter 12 bankruptcies. Here’s their conversation: If you prefer to read along, the transcript is below: Welcome to another American Bankruptcy Institute podcast. I’m Sam Gerdano, ABI executive director. It’s fair to say that the current 115th Congress hasn’t had any legislative achievements this year, given the sharply partisan, if not toxic, environment here in Washington. But, in late October, something bipartisan and good happened. As part of a bill to provide some $36.5 billion in badly needed disaster relief to areas devastated by the fall hurricanes, Congress attached legislation to reauthorize 14 temporary bankruptcy judgeships in danger of expiration, while creating four new temporary positions in districts of need. Congress funded it with an increase in quarterly fees charged to Chapter 11 debtors. The last section of the legislation did something else, too. It amends the Bankruptcy Code to treat tax consequences from the sale of farming property in Chapter 12 as a pre-petition claim, not entitled to priority status, and thus eligible to be discharged in a plan of reorganization. Joe Peiffer is our guest today. He is a lawyer from Cedar Rapids, Iowa who’s been intimately involved with this issue for years, and he joins us today to discuss this new development and its impact, so welcome Joe to ABI Podcasts. JP: Thank you, it’s great to be here. SG: In the coming issue of the ABI Journal, you write about the tortured history of this legislative fix, and we will indeed get into a bit of that area, but first, let’s start with the basics. What does this amendment do and what problem does it solve for Chapter 12 debtors? JP: What this amendment does is reverse the United States Supreme Court Case, Hall vs. United States, and in the Hall case which came down May 14, 2012, the Supreme Court held that the taxes that accrue from the sale of farm assets after filing the bankruptcy cannot be afforded special treatment that Congress had put in as part of BAPCPA. In part of BAPCPA, Congress sought to have the taxes on the sale of farm assets used in the debtor’s farming operation treated as a pre-petition, unsecured claim. Unfortunately, Congress was inarticulate and the Supreme Court, while being able to understand that that was indeed the intent of Congress, said that it did not write it in a fashion that would allow the Court to determine that the taxes could be de-prioritized. And it basically sent it back to Congress to rewrite the statute. SG: And in Congress, in fact, over the years since 2012, has attempted to legislatively overturn Hall, which we should mention was a 5-4 decision, a close, close, call, and did deal with statutory interpretation and as you point out, the imprecision of the language being perhaps contrary to the legislative history and legislative intent. So what happened to legislatively overturn Hall in the past. I take it they didn’t succeed? JP: None of them succeeded. In September of 2012, a bill was introduced by Senator Grassley and Senator Franken. It was assigned to the Senate Finance Committee, where it died at the end of the 112th Congress. Then, in January I believe, of ’13, a new bill was introduced, and that bill was initially assigned to the Senate Finance Committee, and it was then moved to the Senate Judiciary Committee, where it languished till the end of the 113th Congress. The 114th Congress reintroduced the bill that had been introduced in the 113th Congress. It was assigned to Senate Judiciary and died. And finally, in the 115th Congress, the one we have, Senator Grassley and Senator Franken reintroduced the same bill that had been introduced in the 113th and 114th Congress on May 25th of this year, and it became essentially the law that was signed by President Trump on October 26th. SG: And happily, the circumstance that helped distinguish this latest effort was as I mentioned at the outset, the underlying legislation, which was a must-pass item creating, authorizing disaster funding relief for areas affected by the hurricane. In addition to that, it became a vehicle for the judgeship bill, which had also languished over the last couple of Congresses, so that’s how Washington works. JP: Right. Senator Coons and Senator Grassley worked together. Senator Coons, from Delaware, wanted the bankruptcy judgeships. Senator Grassley wanted the Chapter 12 fix, and so they worked together to negotiate on that and those two ideas were put together in one bill. And then that bill had passed the Senate and was waiting at the House, and then the House decided they wanted to do the supplemental appropriations, and they wanted a vehicle with which to send it back to the Senate, where there would be minimal debate, and this bill happened to be poised and waiting when House Appropriations moved forward. SG: Right. Sometimes you’ve gotta be lucky in the legislative process as well. Even for issues that are relatively non-controversial, as this, I think, was. At the end of the day, nobody disagreed with the idea that Hall was perhaps even technically correct, but not faithful to the original Congressional intent, so there was support for changing the law, but we just needed the appropriate timing and vehicle to do it. So let me ask you Joe, what is the, you described the change and why it’s necessary. What’s the effective date of this change? Will it help debtors in cases that are pending now? JP: It will help family farmers in Chapter 12 that have not confirmed their plan of reorganization. If a plan of reorganization has been or was confirmed before October 26, the effective date of the legislation, this will not affect them. If, and I have four cases right now that were filed in late August, early September, it affects all of them, and they can all use this legislation.
Joe Peiffer on the Big Show

Joe Peiffer recently chatted with Doug Cooper, one of the hosts of the Big Show on WMT and other midwest radio stations, about the changes in Chapter 12 bankruptcy laws and the current farm economy. Here are the first two segments of that interview (We will update this post when more segments have aired). If you would prefer to read the transcripts, you may find them below. Part 1: (Aired 11/6/2017) Part 2: (Aired 11/7/2017) Part 1: Doug Cooper: Cedar Rapids lawyer Joe Peiffer has been working, basically since the farm crisis in the 80s, to get Chapter 12 in place and workable. Joe, give us a little history here: Joe Peiffer: Doug, back in 1986, Senator Grassley and Congress responded to the farm crisis by having Chapter 12 bankruptcy added to the Bankruptcy Code. At the time it was added to the Code, nobody thought, or didn’t have a chance to deal with the tax problems that could arise. Chapter 12 was designed to change the balance of power so that under-secured creditors, Farm Credit, or banks, could not veto a farmer’s Chapter 11 bankruptcy. By going to Chapter 12 there was no veto power in the hands of a creditor which came up in the voting of cases for plan confirmation. Chapter 12 eliminated that so the farmer could show the plan was feasible and they could also show that they met all of the statutory qualifications, they paid creditors as much as they would get in a Chapter 7, their plan would be confirmed and they could continue farming. DC: What happened? JP: Shortly thereafter, we learned that as farmers right-sized their farm by selling assets by selling assets that they didn’t necessarily need to keep operational, there were tax problems and the tax people had a first priority claim meaning that out of unsecured assets, those tax claims had to be paid in full and if there wasn’t enough to show that they could be paid in full over 5 years, the IRS or the state department of revenue could stay to the Court, “The plan doesn’t meet the code requirement of paying us in full over five years, so you can’t confirm it.” At that point, the taxing people controlled whether the farmer could confirm the plan or not. Fast forward from 1986 to 1999. Many people came up with many different ideas trying to solve the problem. None of them went anywhere. In December of 1998, I proposed to Senator Grassley that instead of trying to get the tax paid by taking money to the bankers and paying the IRS, we should move the claim of the IRS from the front of the line to the back of the line so that it would be discharged at the end of the bankruptcy. So if unsecured creditors were going to get perhaps a nickel on the dollar, that’s all the IRS and the state departments of revenue would get, and the plan could be confirmed. Grassley liked the idea. He had his staffers write it up, and in January of ’99, Farm Safety 2000 was introduced by Grassley. I told him that I didn’t like the language and I didn’t think it’d work. They said, “You get this language or no language.” The following year became part of the Bankruptcy Reform Bill of 2000. It was passed by veto-proof margin in both the House and Senate. It went on to President Clinton’s desk and he pocket-vetoed the bill. It wasn’t until 2005 with the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention Consumer Protection Act of 2005 was passed. April 20, 2005 it was signed by President George W. Bush. And it contained the language that had been taken from my idea so that we could make the taxes payable as an unsecured claim. I litigated the first case; a hog farmer out of Mitchell County, Iowa. We went all the way to the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals. And the Eighth Circuit said we did not need to worry, you could file the case, right-size, and then incur the tax and treat it as an unsecured claim at the end of the bankruptcy and it would be discharged. While the Eighth Circuit said that, and the Eighth Circuit does Arkansas, Missouri, Iowa, Nebraska, North Dakota, South Dakota, Minnesota, for those states that worked fine: we could right-size a farm and we could deal with the tax and not have to pay in full. Dark clouds are on the horizon. In the Ninth Circuit, Arizona, California, and some of the western states, a different approach is being taken. The Bankruptcy Court said in the Hall case said, “You’re wrong, Eighth Circuit. Instead, you can’t file bankruptcy, sell the farm, and then have the tax dealt with as an unsecured claim and discharged.” They read the statute literally. District Court reversed them and said, “It’s okay. The Eighth Circuit is right.” The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals said, “No.” At that point, we have a split in the circuits: the Eighth Circuit says a farmer can file bankruptcy, right-size, and deal with the taxes through the bankruptcy plan. Ninth Circuit says no, the farmer can’t file, right-size after filing, and then deal with the taxes. It goes to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court hears arguments in November of 2011 and issues its ruling May 14, 2012. In a 5-4 decision the Supreme Court says, “The farmer cannot file bankruptcy, sell the assets, incur the tax, and deal with it as an unsecured claim. Instead, that claim will survive and will be there when the bankruptcy is over, and the IRS can then collect from the farmer.” That afternoon I had a bill on Grassley’s desk that could change that. Finally now, last week, it was enacted, passed by the senate, went to President Trump’s desk and was signed last Thursday. It is now effective. What the new bill does, that just got passed and enacted, is that it now
