Bankruptcy Can Be A Vital Tool

Last week, in an article by Joe Mahon of the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, attorney Joe Peiffer shared valuable insight into the financial state of Iowa farmers. He also highlighted some potentially troubling issues on the horizon. The main concern Joe raised involves farmers’ borrowing habits. He explained, “…so what they’re doing is that they’re borrowing money on the land,” and as a result, “…increase the amount of payments we’re going to have to make next year.” Refinancing like this does kick the can down the road, but only pushes off addressing the underlying issues farmers face. Pressure is building for these farmers, and the situation may eventually reach a breaking point. Fortunately for them, farmers can currently restructure their debt thanks to the value of their land. Land is a finite resource and will likely retain its value. However, other factors—like declining soil quality—could put that lifeline at risk. It’s wise to have a backup plan. This “ace up your sleeve” could help farmers avoid disaster and start climbing out of debt. While some may shy away from it due to societal stigma, bankruptcy—especially Chapter 12—can be a powerful tool when used properly. For more details on Chapter 12 bankruptcy, check out our previous blog posts: Chapter 12: The Farmer’s Ally in Debt Recovery and Chapter 12 Bankruptcy: Is it Right for Me? or call us to discuss your situation at (319) 363-1641.
The Urgency for Risk Management

Earlier this week, attorney Austin J. Peiffer spoke with Erin Anderson from Brownfield Ag News. Their conversation focused on the urgency of risk management, especially as farm bankruptcies continue to rise. As we noted in our blog When it Comes to Farm Debt – Fish or Cut Bait, the data is clear. The Administrative Office of U.S. Courts reported 181 Chapter 12 bankruptcies filed in the first six months of this year. That’s a 57% increase compared to the same period last year. In all of last year, only 216 cases were filed. The trend is climbing—and experts expect even more filings in the year ahead. These numbers matter. They’re a warning sign. As a farmer or business owner, you can’t control the market. But you can control your own financial preparedness. That starts with being organized, covering all your bases, and doing more than just the basics. In the interview, Austin put it plainly: “If all you’re doing is updating your balance sheet at the end of the year, you’re operating in the dark for the year. If you’re funding your farm by rolling debt onto land or equipment, you might not see year after year your farm is losing money.” The message is simple: be prepared. You might be asking yourself: If so, you’re not alone. Many of our clients come to us with the same concerns. And that’s where Ag & Business Legal Strategies comes in. We’ve helped farmers and business owners manage risk, reorganize debt, and plan ahead—so they can keep farming and running their operations. Don’t wait. Reach out today. We’re here to help.
When it Comes to Farm Debt – Fish or Cut Bait

Of all the services we provide for farmers here at Ag & Business Legal Strategies, maybe the most important comes first: Helping you honestly assess your situation. Earlier this month several articles and editorials came out of a meeting Arkansas farmers had with their Congressional delegation, requesting federal assistance to save their farms. This is far from the first news of the year indicating rising financial troubles for farmers stemming from several contributing factors: continuing low commodity prices, tariffs and other trade challenges impacting global demand for U.S. agricultural goods, higher input costs, and weather events. Farm bankruptcies (Chapter 12) are up sharply in 2025: There is no shame in filing a bankruptcy if debt reorganization or other measures are no longer sufficient to address your farm’s issues. If fear is holding you back, keep in mind that bankruptcy doesn’t necessarily mean giving up your land or livelihood. Bankruptcy provides an opportunity to force a restructuring of farm debts if the farmer can satisfy the requirements of the bankruptcy code. And the sooner you act, the better your chances are of reorganizing instead of liquidating, or even avoiding bankruptcy altogether. If you are not to the point of considering bankruptcy, but still have worries about your farm’s financial situation, it is better to face difficult decisions and take action now—not later. Indecision is a decision to allow others to make decisions for you. Waiting too long means your bank, your landlord, your vendors, and other people’s attorneys will be calling the shots for you. We want to help you determine your own path as much as possible. How farm history matters Even if your farm or ag business is thriving, it’s worth examining if this is a solid streak or simply a good year. For that reason, every farmer and their bookkeeper should set aside time to review the farm’s finances several times a year. Since harvest is underway and the end of the year will be here before we know it, this is as great a time as any! While quick cash seems an attractive option for desperate times because it’s immediately available and the creditor doesn’t require collateral, the tradeoff is immediate fees and, if not paid back within a short time, compounding interest beyond a normal person’s ability to repay. You can read more of our advice on MCA pitfalls, and better alternatives, here. If you need help assessing your farm’s financial situation, Ag & Business Legal Strategies offers enterprise analysis. This examines the individual parts making up your farm or ag business to show you how each is contributing to profit and loss. Find out more about how this planning tool can save you lots of future time and trouble here. (319) 363-1641 Cash isn’t necessarily financial health Even if you have a positive bank balance, that should not be your only metric for financial stability. Cash on hand doesn’t always indicate profitability, which is tied to management decisions you’ve made that generate income, such as the return on new investment for crops or livestock production. If your positive balance is largely from non-production activities—say, the sale of capital assets (land or equipment, for instance), borrowing funds, or an inheritance payout—you didn’t generate profit. This is important because profit has the possibility of being sustainable, or repeatable. Unless you’ve won a tremendous lottery or your last name is Buffett or Gates, you probably can’t rely on capital gains or a one-time payment as future income. This also applies to cash from refinancing or selling a capital asset, such as taking out a second mortgage. Borrowing and pledging intermediate or long-term assets to make your current situation positive only increases loan payments in future years, further decreasing your ability to cash-flow your operations. We’ve written about profitability versus cash-on-hand in the blog before, which you can find here. The only failure is avoidance This has been a tough year on many farmers, not just in the upper Midwest. With lower commodity prices and higher costs, even if the past few years have been boom, you could be facing difficulties this year in paying all your creditors on time. Whether it’s rent, a bank loan repayment, or what you owe vendors, you need to know who has first security interest in your crops and other farm products so you can structure payments to creditors. In many instances, there will be more claims against the crops and other farm products than the cash from selling those assets. This is another topic we tackled previously, about this time last year. You can read more about collateral, liens, the danger of selling collateral without authorization to pay debts, and how our attorneys can help with negotiations here. If the above is the situation you believe you’ll find yourself in post-harvest, it is time to evaluate your options NOW so you can be proactive in addressing deficits. Ag & Business Legal Strategies has been helping farmers with this problem for many years. One of the reasons we started this blog was to help farmers and small business owners better understand not only the options available to address their financial and legal problems, but how imperative it is to seek assistance as soon as they realize they have a problem. You may have heard that failure to prepare is preparing to fail. We say that failure to make a decision IS a decision—to let others decide for you. Farm debt not dealt with in a timely manner leads to consequences that can range from bad to catastrophic, including added default interest, legal action, seizure of property, and possibly imprisonment for farmers who sell collateral without authorization and do not pay the secured creditor. The earlier you act, the better chance you have to maintain control of decisions over your own future. (319) 363-1641 At Ag & Business Legal Strategies, we want our clients to be honest with themselves and have a solid business plan. Our team will help you create and execute
Influencing Legislation: Putting Your Voice to Work for Laws

Be honest: What comes immediately to mind when someone talks about how Congress makes a law? For generations of Americans it’s the 1976 “I’m Just a Bill” episode of Schoolhouse Rock. It was a catchy introduction when we were young, but we soon learn there’s much more to the process than, “He signed you, Bill! Now you’re a law!” Your participation in democracy doesn’t have to end at the ballot box. You can tell your legislators what laws you’d like to see, or which you oppose. There’s an old saying that “if you don’t vote, you can’t complain”—the same could be said of legislation that passes, if you don’t share concerns with your members of Congress. My hope here is to help you effectively do that and feel comfortable doing so. If you already know the finer points of crafting legislation, you may want to skip over this next section. For everyone else, here’s a quick overview of lawmaking at the federal level. Journey from bill to law Any legislator can create and introduce a bill in their chamber of Congress, the Senate or House of Representatives. It is then assigned to the proper committee, which may hold hearings, conduct research, and possibly rewrite parts of the bill. If the bill is to advance and not just languish in committee, it needs to be voted out of committee to the full Senate or House—where the Speaker of the House or the Majority Leader of the Senate can decide whether to allow it to come to the floor for debate and a vote. The committee could alternately decide to just study the matter longer, or vote to kill the bill. One note on the above is that bills that expressly require federal funding must start in the House. Once on the full House or Senate floor, a bill can pass to the other chamber after it receives a majority of “yes” votes—51 in the Senate or 218 in the House. There are some rules unique to the Senate, however, that can put a snag in this process. One is the fact that any Senator, for any reason, can place a hold on legislation and prevent it from coming to a vote. Another rule is the filibuster, which is designed to delay the voting process. Under filibuster, a member can talk on the Senate floor as long as they like, about the bill or any topic, and no vote can be taken until they are finished. Cloture is a way around the filibuster—if a Senator invokes cloture and at least 60 members vote to agree on that, it ends all debate, filibusters, and holds and forces another vote on the bill itself. Probably the latest example of cloture at the writing of this article was on March 14 when several Democrats joined Republicans 62-38 to force a vote on the stopgap spending bill to avert government shutdown. For the sake of argument and to keep this short, let’s say the House or Senate does approve a bill and sends it to the other, but the second chamber makes some changes to pass it. This creates two versions, which must go to a reconciliation committee made up equally of Senators and Representatives. If they can agree on a single compromise version, that’s what goes back to both House and Senate for votes. Once both chambers have approved the same language—whether on first pass or through reconciliation—it goes to the White House, where the President has 10 days (minus Sundays) to sign it into law or expressly veto it and state their objections. If they fail to sign or veto the bill in that time, it automatically becomes law. A vetoed bill that can win a two-thirds “yes” in each chamber (67 in the Senate, 290 in the House) will become law… but this doesn’t happen often. One more note about veto power: If Congress sends the President a bill but adjourns before the 10 days is up, making the President unable to return an express veto, he or she can do nothing and kill the bill with a pocket veto. Congress can’t override this type of veto, so the process would need to start all over again with the introduction of a new bill. An example of ongoing advocacy For more than 30 years, I have been involved in federal legislative efforts both as a concerned citizen and an attorney who represents farmers. I have had successes, such as when I helped write legislation for Chapter 12 bankruptcy that addresses farmers’ unique concerns. And then there are issues that take longer to solve, which I continue to work on with legislators. One longtime cause is venue reform for bankruptcy cases. I believe large companies filing Chapter 11 bankruptcy should be required to do so in the court closest to where they conduct business, but there is a loophole in federal law that permits them to set up subsidiaries in other states with courts historically sympathetic to the specific relief the corporation desires. Having that subsidiary organized in a favored state allows not only the subsidiary to file there, but by extension, the parent corporation to be able to do the same—often far from their creditors. This tactic has been used to deny farmers and other creditors fair payment for supplies and services when massive corporate assets are liquidated. It happened when ethanol manufacturer VeraSun Energy, headquartered in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, filed its Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2008—in Delaware, a state notably lacking in ethanol plants or cornfields—leaving many Midwest farmers with grain contracts holding the bag. Just last month, crop ag-tech firm Benson Hill headquartered just outside St. Louis filed its Chapter 11 in faraway Delaware, as well. Why is this issue important to farmers? Bankruptcy proceedings happening several states away discourage creditors who can’t take the time or afford to travel from attending to testify or observe. Also, if I’m representing an Iowa farmer in a Delaware courtroom, we need to hire an extra lawyer who is licensed in that state
Avoid Getting Crossways With Creditors when Income is Short

Harvest is here—the culmination of months of sweat, toil, worry, and investment. Hopefully your harvest is safe and smooth, your yields are excellent, and your marketing gets you excellent prices. If either your yields or prices are low, however, you might worry about coming up short. Nobody wants to shortchange their landlords or vendors, but you also have to pay the bank. Which creditors should you pay when funds are short—and what happens if you don’t? Collateral is Key When you borrow input financing you sign a security agreement with the bank. You might not remember that you signed it, or it may have been years ago, but it states that all your inputs, crops, and government program payments (and maybe other property as well) are collateral for your debts to the bank. “Collateral” has two important practical meanings. First, if you don’t pay your debts, the bank can seize and sell the collateral to pay the debt. And even if you’re current with your debts, the bank still has an interest in that collateral, and you can’t just do what you please with it or the proceeds you might get from selling it, you’ll need to use the proceeds to pay off the lien. When things are good and there’s enough money to go around, your bank might not worry much about this. If the bank is happy, it might not look too hard to see if you paid a landlord or a vendor with crop proceeds before paying off your input note. However, when there’s not enough money to go around, the bank might view this as taking money out of its pocket. Landlords and certain other vendors have statutory liens on your crop. Most of the time these don’t matter because those creditors don’t properly perfect (or enforce) them, but if they do, in many instances these statutory liens can jump ahead of the bank in the payment line and legally say, “Sorry bank, but I get paid before you do.” For more information, refer to our February 2024 blog post Landlord’s Liens: Cheap, Easy, but Time-Critical Insurance. Creditors’ Rights A creditor who has your crop or other farm products as collateral has the right to demand a list of potential buyers and send notices to them to get their name on your checks. As with statutory liens, this right affords secured creditors extra protection but isn’t frequently used; however, just because yours is the only name on the check doesn’t mean your secured creditors lost their security when you sold the collateral. The creditors who had your crop as collateral still have a right to its proceeds—whether or not their name is on the check! When faced with the question of who to pay first when selling your crop or other collateral, the law says the creditor with the senior lien on the collateral gets paid in full first, then down the line from there, any leftover proceeds only going to you once all the lienholders are paid in full. The law doesn’t care who you want to pay or who deserves to get paid—it is concerned only with who has a lien on the collateral and their place in line. Better Permission Than Forgiveness The law can put a farmer in a bind when there’s not enough money to go around. If your landlord isn’t paid, that would likely damage a longstanding relationship and they might even terminate your lease. Your vendor may also be your neighbor or relative. And you still need to put food on the table and support your family. Sometimes borrowers choose to pay the bills they want to pay first and then hope that somehow everything will work out or the bank will ignore this transgression even though the input loan isn’t paid off. This is a dangerous path to take, since it can damage your relationship with your banker and lead to civil and even criminal liability. It’s better to clear your plans with your banker before acting on them, then consult an experienced ag attorney, such as those with Ag & Business Legal Strategies—especially if you can’t reach a deal. Conversion Selling collateral and using the proceeds, without authorization, for anything other than paying off lienholders in their proper order is conversion, which is the civil counterpart of theft. If a farmer wants to get a check without a secured creditor’s name on it and sells farm products to a buyer whom they haven’t disclosed to the secured creditor who requested disclosure, that’s conversion as well, and doing this makes using those proceeds for something other than paying off lienholders in their proper order even more blatantly wrong. In some circumstances conversion might constitute theft. Conversion can also be grounds for a debt to be nondischargeable in a bankruptcy. Nondischargeability means the debt survives bankruptcy, even though bankruptcy is meant to provide a fresh start by discharging most debts. If you choose to ask for forgiveness rather than permission in these circumstances, you need to know the stakes. Far too often a farmer comes to us after they’ve converted collateral and failed to pay off the senior lienholders, leaving us struggling to salvage something from a bad situation. If these farmers had come to us before converting collateral, we might have been able to obtain a better outcome. When we have to try to pick up the pieces after collateral has already been converted, we often negotiate settlements with the creditor in which some or all of the debt will be nondischargeable in a bankruptcy—and it almost always costs the farmer a lot of time, energy, angst, and legal fees. Act Now to Avoid Creditor Problems If you think you might be short on income this year, contact Ag & Business Legal Strategies right away. We can help you analyze which creditors have your crop as collateral and try to negotiate a resolution that achieves your goals and helps you avoid trouble. Contact us now to discuss your situation, rather than
Chapter 12: The Farmer’s Ally in Debt Recovery

Farmers are special in many ways. John F. Kennedy said, “The farmer is the only man in our economy who has to buy everything he buys at retail—sell everything he sells at wholesale—and pay the freight both ways.” Farmers form the foundation of our nation’s food supply. In recognition of their unique place in our economy (and of their lobbying prowess), farmers have access to specialized tools in bankruptcy that no other debtors have. This starts with Chapter 12 of the Bankruptcy Code. Why Chapter 12? In legal parlance, “chapter” is a shorthand way of referring to a bankruptcy filed under that specific chapter of the Bankruptcy Code. Individuals usually file Chapter 7 (liquidation) or Chapter 13 (repayment plan) bankruptcies. While businesses can liquidate through Chapter 7, they most often reorganize through Chapter 11 bankruptcies. Small businesses can take advantage of Chapter 11 Subchapter V bankruptcies. Chapter 15 bankruptcies are for international companies to file. And family farmers and family fishermen can file under Chapter 12. Chapter 12 has the same basic thrust as other reorganization (Chapter 11 of all varieties) or repayment (Chapter 13) bankruptcies: Paying creditors fairly while allowing the business or individual to escape overwhelming debt loads and hopefully continue being productive members of society. However, Chapter 12—particularly for family farmers—gives overwhelmed debtor options unavailable in other bankruptcy chapters. A full list of these differences is the topic of an hour-long continuing legal education course for lawyers (Ag & Business Legal Strategies attorneys have taught courses like this), so we’ll focus on one near and dear to our hearts: Tax deprioritization. Taking the Bite out of Taxes Benjamin Franklin famously quipped, “In this world nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes.” In all chapters of bankruptcy, taxes are granted special “priority” status, meaning they get paid first in a liquidation and must be paid in full in a reorganization or repayment plan. If they are not paid, they are not discharged at the end of the bankruptcy. In contrast, non-priority “general” unsecured claims typically receive pennies on the dollar and are practically always discharged at the end of the case. The problem is that in a typical farm Chapter 12, the debtor has sold or needs to sell farm property to right-size their operation so it is profitable—but those sale proceeds have to pay down the bank and other secured creditors, leaving no money to pay tax bills that are frequently massive. This can force farmers to liquidate instead of reorganizing. Chapter 12 allows family farmers to turn the tables on the tax man. Under Chapter 12 a family farmer can treat the taxes from liquidated farm assets as general unsecured claims (and therefore typically to be paid pennies on the dollar) and discharge any unpaid taxes at the end of the bankruptcy. This can save a Chapter 12 family farm debtor tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars. How does Ag & Business Legal Strategies know so much about tax deprioritization for family farmers? We regularly file for clients under Chapter 12 and deprioritize their taxes—Ag & Business Legal Strategies filed the first case to use tax deprioritization, in fact, and we’ve helped family farmers deprioritize hundreds of thousands of dollars in taxes. We also often speak and write about Chapter 12 and tax deprioritization. Most of all, our firm’s founder, Joe Peiffer, helped draft the tax deprioritization statutory language, twice—both originally and then again after the Supreme Court found the flaw he had identified in the original language. Here to Help At Ag & Business Legal Strategies we often describe Chapter 12 as the most powerful chapter in the Bankruptcy Code. Tax deprioritization, a high debt limit, and the ability to confirm a reorganization plan without having to persuade creditors to support it are just some of the reasons it deserves that distinction. If you’re a struggling family farmer or know one, reach out to Ag & Business Legal Strategies today. We can help you evaluate your farm business as a whole and, if appropriate, help you file a Chapter 12 bankruptcy, right-size your operation, and deprioritize the taxes from those liquidations. Contact us now—we can do so much more to assist you if we’re brought in early, rather than after everything is falling apart. At Ag & Business Legal Strategies, we want our clients to be honest with themselves and have a solid business plan. Our attorneys and financial strategist will help you create and execute that business plan, and, if necessary, assist you with the legal, tax, and practical aspects of debt restructuring or bankruptcy. Don’t wait for the problems to become insurmountable. Connect with someone you can trust today, not tomorrow. Contact Us
Defending Against Preference Repayment Demands

Taking a break from the morning’s work, you stop by the mailbox only to find an unfamiliar envelope from some law firm. The letter inside is notification that the XYZ Grain Elevator has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy reorganization, and as part of this, you might have to turn over to the court a good chunk of the $50,000 soybean check you received two months ago! Are you legally obligated to return your payment so XYZ’s other creditors can be paid? What are your options, and can you effectively defend your right to keep what you were owed? What is bankruptcy preference? In bankruptcy parlance, a “preference” is receipt of payment or other transfer of assets from a debtor to a creditor that takes place during or shortly in advance of the debtor filing for bankruptcy protection. It’s called that because it appears the debtor (XYZ Grain Elevator) is showing preference to this particular creditor (you) by paying them while leaving other creditors unpaid. It means you are potentially receiving a better payment than the court would be able to distribute among XYZ’s other creditors after liquidation of its assets through the bankruptcy process. A preference, therefore, enhances the preferred creditor’s recovery at the expense of similarly situated creditors. Let’s consider Bill, who decides he’s going to pay half the $50,000 he owes on a used tractor, to get the dealer, ABC Equipment, to stop haranguing him for payment. If Bill pays $25,000 and files for bankruptcy shortly thereafter, ABC Equipment has received 50 cents on the dollar of what it is owed, when the bankruptcy court might later determine all creditors will only be paid 10 cents on the dollar. That is a preferential payment, and the bankruptcy trustee could send ABC a letter demanding it return most of Bill’s $25,000 payment to the court, to be split among other unpaid creditors. Preference recoveries allow the bankruptcy court to “level the playing field” so all creditors get a fair shot at their percentage share of the debtor’s liquidated assets as repayment. Time limits on preference There is a “lookback period” to define what is a preferential payment. For general creditors, it’s within 90 days before the filing for bankruptcy. If Bill pays ABC Equipment $25,000 on June 30 and files on September 10, the trustee could send ABC a demand letter. But it’s not just what day the check was issued. If Bill doesn’t file for bankruptcy until October 30 but ABC waited until August 10 to deposit his check, ABC could still be subject to a demand letter. The 90-day lookback period is extended to one full year for creditors considered to be “insiders,” such as family members up to three degrees removed (up to a third cousin) or partner in a business. Consider the situation with Bill above. Let’s change the situation so that his first cousin, Tom, is actually a co-owner in ABC Equipment. In this case, the bankruptcy trustee could look all the way back to October 30 the previous year for any possible preferential payments. Congress believed “blood is thicker than water,” and that chances are high a debtor will pay their relatives before general unsecured creditors. One additional note on preferential payments: These are not just checks or cash payments, but any transfer of assets to satisfy a debt. For example, if a debtor transfers title to their vacation home to a creditor within the lookback period, the trustee and court could view that as a preferential payment. Mounting a defense No matter what kind of bankruptcy a debtor files—Chapter 7, 11, 12, or 13—the same federal code applies with respect to preferential payments. If you receive a demand letter as a creditor, it is important that you determine whether you have a valid defense against preference repayment. The best course is to consult with an attorney who knows the Bankruptcy Code and how to deal with preference demand. We have represented clients on both sides of preference letters. There are four types of defense a creditor may use against a preference letter. Don’t fear being paid Farmers selling grain or livestock do have some federal and state regulatory protections. The federal Packers & Stockyards Act regulates how quickly livestock and poultry producers must be paid, which is often a solid defense against preference repayment demands. State licensing requirements and grain indemnity funds are typically in place to cover grain elevator defaults. A farmer with these protections might still receive a preference demand letter, but these regulatory protections can help mount a defense. Ag & Business Legal Strategies recommends keeping records on your sales & purchases for your farm or business and tracking when you are paid & if you are not getting paid on time. If you are owed money, keep pursuing payment from a debtor—don’t let the prospect of a preference letter later on keep you from accepting payment. Remember, getting paid for certain with only a possibility of having to pay part of the money back is better than having your whole accounts receivable sitting out there and getting cents on the dollar in a hypothetical bankruptcy. If you receive a preference demand letter from a debtor or trustee, be proactive and reach out to us. Don’t wait—do it right away! At Ag & Business Legal Strategies, we want our clients to be honest with themselves and have a solid business plan. Our attorneys and financial strategist will help you create and execute that business plan, and, if necessary, assist you with the legal, tax, and practical aspects of debt restructuring or bankruptcy. Don’t wait for the problems to become insurmountable. Connect with someone you can trust today, not tomorrow.
From Debt to Deliverance: Wade

Note: This is the final installment of a three-part blog series about ABLS clients and their debt resolution stories. In March and April, we shared the debt restructuring stories of retired and active Iowa farmers Jerry and Deb, and Paul and Linda, respectively. In this blog, meet a third Iowa farmer: Wade. Wade had his hands full with two business ventures in northern Iowa. He was farming several hundred acres of corn and soybeans, and co-owned a small trucking business. Then, in the space of four years, it all turned sour. From bad to worse As Wade tells it, “I was farming with a business partner at a trucking company. He got himself in a little trouble. I had to buy him out, which wasn’t a bad deal, but then four years after that I ended up going through a divorce. After getting through that, the president of the bank I was working with retired and the loan officer I was working with left – all in about three months. A whole new crew of people came in and the new president wouldn’t work with me.” The banker wanted Wade to liquidate assets to meet his loan payments. Wade began by selling his cattle and some machinery. It wasn’t enough and the bank encouraged Wade to sell his land. Wade was on a path to leaving farming altogether. He didn’t want that to happen. Piecing together a solution We met Wade in 2017 and began piecing together a debt restructuring plan. As with the two farm couples we featured before, Chapter 12 bankruptcy was the best option. The bank fought the February 2018 bankruptcy filing that called for Wade to use cash collateral to plant crops that spring. Ultimately, the bankruptcy plan was confirmed that December. Wade got to keep his remaining machinery and land. He’s running a more efficient operation today, and is coming off the best two years he’s had as a farmer. What’s more, he still runs his trucking company. Wade says he wouldn’t still be farming without the legal help he received from Joe Peiffer and financial advice from Keith Starr. “Joe and Keith made me a way better manager than I was before,” he says. “Now, I’m taking every purchase into consideration and paying cash. It’s nice to have cash in the bank, when before it was always buy it now and pay for it later. Working with Joe and Keith changed my whole perspective.” Time is of the essence “I would recommend any farmer in a situation like mine to talk to them,” Wade says. “They can probably fix things so you don’t have to go the full nine yards (toward exiting farming) like I had to. “My biggest regret is – and I can’t stress it enough – is that I didn’t talk to them sooner.” If farm debt is becoming unmanageable for you, be proactive and reach out to us. Don’t wait – do it today. At Ag & Business Legal Strategies, we want our clients to be honest with themselves and have a solid business plan. Our attorneys and financial strategist will help you create and execute that business plan, and, if necessary, assist you with the legal, tax, and practical aspects of debt restructuring or bankruptcy. Don’t wait for the problems to become insurmountable. Connect with someone you can trust today, not tomorrow.
From Debt to Deliverance: Paul and Linda

Note: This is the second of a three-part blog series about ABLS clients and their debt resolution stories. In March we shared the story of retired Iowa farmers Jerry and Deb and the debt restructuring plan we developed for them. In this blog meet another Iowa farm couple, Paul and Linda. An average crop in 2012, a worse crop in 2013 and no crop in 2014 was the beginning of Paul’s and Linda’s woes in eastern Iowa. Paul described what happened next: “We lost one of the farms that we were (working), and that was a third of our acreage for farming. So we didn’t have enough acres to cover our leftover expenses the following year. Plus, the co-op we were working with was hedged-to-arrive and had a change of management, and those people didn’t understand hedge-to-arrive, and forced us to sell at a high tide and we were on the wrong side of the market. That left a deficit that was impossible to overcome.” On top of that, the couple’s bank had a change in management. The new management didn’t understand farming. Paul told bank managers if they wouldn’t work with him on loan repayment he would have to declare bankruptcy and face a tax bill he and Linda couldn’t afford. Body shop, healthy body, and hope We first met with the couple in 2015, shortly after Linda was diagnosed with a form of blood cancer. We determined they couldn’t work through their debt issues outside of bankruptcy, even with the income Paul received from his body shop business. Paul and Linda filed for Chapter 12 in April 2016, and the bankruptcy court confirmed their reorganization plan in early 2017. Paul was able to continue running his body shop and, in fact, has expanded his business. Linda is now cancer-free and sells essential oils. The couple no longer farm but still live in their home post-bankruptcy, and the Chapter 12 addressed their tax bill. It all works out “I grew up on a farm and farmed for 40 years. It was a way of life,” Paul says. “To stop farming was very difficult, but when you have someone like Joe Peiffer reassuring you that everything will work out, it was an easy decision to file Chapter 12.” If farm debt is becoming unmanageable for you, be proactive and reach out to us. Don’t wait – do it today. At Ag & Business Legal Strategies, we want our clients to be honest with themselves and have a solid business plan. Our attorneys and financial strategist will help you create and execute that business plan, and, if necessary, assist you with the legal, tax, and practical aspects of debt restructuring or bankruptcy. Don’t wait for the problems to become insurmountable. Connect with someone you can trust today, not tomorrow.
From Debt to Deliverance: Jerry and Deb

Poor crops. A barn fire. Disabling injuries. New bank managers who don’t know you and are less cooperative than the ones they replaced. Our clients have experienced devastating events like these, and more. Events that threatened to leave them destitute. In this month’s blog, and in April and May, we’ll share stories of three farm families who accumulated stifling debt and came out the other side with financial stability and peace of mind working with us. We begin with Jerry and Deb: Jerry and Deb were living comfortably on their eastern Iowa farm. Between raising Simmental cattle breeding stock, Jerry’s construction business, and Deb’s job at a local community college, all was right with the couple entering the new millennium. Trial by fire, and then some Then came 2002. A barn fire destroyed their feed inventory, and most of the machinery housed inside. Insurance was $60,000 short of replacing what was lost. “It was almost a precursor of what was to come,” Deb says. A 2005 drought hurt Jerry’s hay production, forcing him to dip into winter feed for his cattle. Moving hay one day Jerry was thrown from a four-wheeler, breaking both arms. He recovered just in time to shatter a leg and ankle in 2006 when a scaffold he was standing on gave way. Further pain arrived in 2008 when the farm economy cratered. The couple rapidly accumulated hundreds of thousands of dollars of debt. Their bank demanded loan payments – money Jerry and Deb didn’t have. Foreclosure loomed large. “In 2006 I felt we could come out of it, so we kept plugging away,” Jerry says. “Then 2008 hit and the financial institution matter happened, and I thought that would be the end of us.” An alternate bankruptcy plan Jerry and Deb talked with financial advisors, who recommended they file Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Jerry refused, convinced there was a better way. “I gave Joe Peiffer a call and he said, ‘No, you don’t want to file Chapter 11. You should file Chapter 12,’” Jerry says. “He probably knew the Chapter 12 tax code better than anyone else in Iowa.” Chapter 12 was written in the wake of the farm crisis in the 1980s, but Joe had recently helped rewrite it to give family farmers tax relief. Chapter 12 is specific to family farmers and fisherman and allows them to avoid foreclosure and reorganize their operations or liquidate in a controlled manner. Freedom from debt Over the next 12 months we met several times with the couple and accompanied them to mediation with the bank. Jerry and Deb sold some acreage and more cattle as we began crafting a bankruptcy plan. The Chapter 12 plan was filed in late 2009 and called for complete liquidation. The rest of the farm was auctioned off. “We sold the remaining ground, buildings, the construction equipment, farm equipment, household items and our home, all in one day,” Jerry says. Through Chapter 12 Jerry and Deb were able to discharge $49,741 in 2009 federal and state income taxes for pre-petition sales and approximately $25,000 taxes for the post-petition sales of assets. Today, Jerry and Deb are retired and living in northwest Arkansas, debt- and worry-free. “We would not have the life that we’re leading today if it weren’t for Joe,” Deb says. If farm debt is becoming unmanageable for you, be proactive and reach out to us. Don’t wait – do it today. At Ag & Business Legal Strategies, we want our clients to be honest with themselves and have a solid business plan. Our attorneys and financial strategist will help you create and execute that business plan, and, if necessary, assist you with the legal, tax, and practical aspects of debt restructuring or bankruptcy. Don’t wait for the problems to become insurmountable. Connect with someone you can trust today, not tomorrow.
Unintended Consequences: The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022’s Farm Debt Relief Causes Farmers Massive Tax Headaches

For a deeper analysis into this topic, see a version of this article written for tax professionals and other interested parties here. On August 16, 2022, President Biden signed the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) into law. Section 22006 of the IRA provided $3.1 billion for the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) to provide relief for distressed borrowers under certain Farm Service Agency (FSA) direct and guaranteed loans. On October 18, 2022, USDA provided nearly $800 million in assistance to distressed borrowers to help cure delinquencies and resolve uncollectable farm loan debts: Unintended Consequences of the IRA Payments Farm debt relief is certainly welcome, especially to its recipients. However, when Congress authorized the IRA payments it did not consider that those payments would be counted as income for many recipients, leading to: Two Distressed Borrowers, Similar Problems Consider these two typical borrowers with FSA debts who are in currently not collectible (CNC) status, both of whom benefitted from IRA farm debt relief: Scenario 1: In 2010, Robert defaulted on his FSA-direct loan, which was secured by a lien on his property. When he could not obtain further financing, he could not continue his farming business and the loan went into default. FSA foreclosed, leaving a $100,000 deficiency judgment. Although FSA initially contacted Robert to collect on the debt after the foreclosure, the account was moved into CNC status, where it has remained for 12 years. As of 2022, his past due balance was $150,000, with interest.[1] Scenario 2: Charles has been in default on his FSA-guaranteed loan from a local bank for several years. Charles has continued to farm while working with his bank under forbearance agreements. The debt was moved to the CNC status in 2019. In October of 2022, FSA repaid his entire guaranteed loan to local bank. The payment consisted of principal of $400,000 and interest of $12,000. Now, instead of owing a long-term debt to his bank, with low payments and the option of obtaining a forbearance, he faces a large tax liability (equal to multiple years of payments) due all at once. IRA’s Effects: Increased Taxes While the IRA’s debt relief payments could have many consequences for recipients, for Robert and Charles the primary consequences are increased federal income taxes. Because of this repayment Robert could owe $24,000 or more in additional federal income taxes, and Charles $96,000. Since this debt relief was targeted at farmers who were behind on their payments, Robert and Charles likely cannot pay these bills. Current Nonviable and Viable Options Robert and Charles do have options to address their taxes, but all of them have significant downsides. However, two of the common tools for addressing these taxes are off the table from the get-go. Bankruptcy will not help Robert or Charles any time soon, because these tax debts will be nondischargeable (they will survive a bankruptcy) until at least 2026. Similarly, while insolvent taxpayers don’t pay tax on debt cancellation, that does not apply to a debt repayment like this. Robert and Charles could enter into an installment agreement to pay off their tax debts (with interest and penalties) over six year, if the IRS agrees and they can afford that additional cost. They could make an offer in compromise to the IRS to reduce the amount they owe, but that is a lengthy, difficult, and expensive process, often requiring professional assistance. Moreover, the IRS can take up to two years to review an offer in compromise. USDA is Considering Options to Assist Farmers with their Income Tax Problems. After being informed of the significant problems caused by the repayment of the debt for over 13,000 farmers, the USDA has held a series of meeting and considered three options to ease the income tax problems experienced by farmers: asking the IRS to streamline and ease offer in compromise criteria, giving farmers the option to retroactively opt out of this debt relief, and recharacterizing this debt repayment as debt cancellation instead. The USDA is also considering asking the IRS to grant IRA farm debt relief beneficiaries an extension of time to file their tax returns so they can better plan for and adapt to this unexpected income. It is also considering sponsoring professional tax assistance for affected farmers. Get the Advice You Need and Contact your Members of Congress! If you or someone you know received IRA farm debt relief but now don’t know how to deal with the tax consequences contact Ag & Business Legal Strategies today! We can assist in assessing the consequences, navigating the options, and making an informed decision. Moreover, contact your members of Congress! Tell them USDA needs to find ways to help farmers with the unforeseen tax consequences of the IRA’s farm debt relief. Download a letter template here. Read a deeper analysis here. [1] Thanks to Kristine Tidgren of Iowa State University’s Center for Agricultural Law and Taxation for Robert’s scenario.
Purdue Pharma Bankruptcy: A Battle Over Much More Than Dollars and Cents

In 2019, opioid manufacturer Purdue Pharma filed bankruptcy in the Southern District of New York. A large portion of the debt listed on its bankruptcy schedules came from judgments and potential lawsuits against it for its role in the opioid epidemic. Purdue’s owners, the Sackler family, were named in many of those lawsuits and would likely have been named in many more. Within Purdue’s bankruptcy the Sackler family obtained protection from lawsuits against its members for claims related to Purdue Pharma while the bankruptcy was pending, protection that they continue to enjoy to this day. However, this was only the beginning of the protections the Sacklers sought through Purdue’s bankruptcy. As part of a settlement agreement the Sacklers sought releases from liability for any lawsuits related to Purdue Pharma, even after the bankruptcy concluded. The Sacklers wanted what are known as nonconsensual third-party releases—releases from liability for non-debtors (since none of the Sacklers have filed for bankruptcy) on claims by creditors of the bankruptcy debtor without those creditors’ consent. In exchange for their third-party releases the Sacklers agreed to pay billions of dollars into Purdue Pharma’s reorganization plan. Indeed, Purdue Pharma’s reorganization plan was built around the Sacklers’ payments and liability release. Multiple creditors objected to the reorganization plan as it was proposed to the court, but after careful consideration Judge Robert Drain confirmed the plan over those objections in September of 2021. Judge Drain noted that approving the proposed plan, with nonconsensual third-party releases for the Sackler family, seemed to address the needs of all creditors, including the personal injury claimants, as thoroughly as possible considering the financial status of the company. After Judge Drain’s ruling it appeared that any future claimant seeking to recover damages in relation to the opioid epidemic would not have the option to file suit against the Sacklers directly. On Appeal It didn’t take long for confirmation of Purdue’s Chapter 11 plan to be appealed, and in December of 2021, District Court Judge Colleen McMahon pointed a fresh set of eyes at the situation. In her opinion, she lingered on the fact that members of the Sackler family withdrew upwards of $11 billion from Purdue Pharma in advance of the bankruptcy filing and that these same members knew of the pending wave of litigation headed their way. Then, in exchange for paying $4.35 billion into the bankruptcy settlement, the Sackler family and other “Shareholder Released Parties” received the assurance that all future personal injury claims against them would be channeled through the trusts created by the plan. Though on the surface that seemed like a fair treatment, further examination revealed that the trusts created under the plan would not permit payment to parties with claims against any of the Shareholder Released Parties, so those claims were essentially extinguished without any recourse for the claimants. Though the glaring unfairness made the confirmed plan problematic, Judge McMahon’s decision to vacate Judge Drain’s ruling boiled down to whether the bankruptcy court had the statutory authority to grant the non-debtor release in the first place. With respect to that issue, she held that the Bankruptcy Code did not authorize such third-party releases in any way, so regardless of how well Judge Drain thought the reorganization plan would have handled claims, the bankruptcy court could not legally confirm it. Despite having already spent almost three years embroiled in the bankruptcy process, Purdue Pharma and the Sacklers were sent back to the drawing board to find an acceptable reorganization plan that the court could and would confirm. Unintended Consequences Though vacating Judge Drain’s confirmation order seems to avoid allowing responsible parties to evade liability, determining whether this was a net positive is difficult. While waiting for their appeal to be heard in the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, Purdue Pharma and members of the Sackler family have been actively engaged in mediation with the objecting creditors to find a settlement that would help to alleviate the opioid crisis. In the meantime, personal injury claimants are playing a different waiting game. The previously confirmed reorganization plan would have allowed victims of the opioid epidemic to start receiving payments from the newly established trusts as early as 2022. However, because the trusts will not be established until a plan is confirmed, those payments will, at the very least, be significantly delayed, if they happen at all. If the parties are ultimately unable to reach a settlement that creates an avenue for claimants to receive payment, victims of the opioid crisis that wish to recover directly from the Sackler family and other Purdue shareholders will be left to fight that battle in the court system. The Sackler family has not filed for bankruptcy. This is one of the complaints about the nonconsensual third-party releases they wanted—they granted the Sacklers protection like they would have received through a bankruptcy (indeed, perhaps even broader than they could have received in a bankruptcy) without subjecting them to the scrutiny bankruptcy entails. However, this is a double-edge sword. Since the Sacklers have not filed bankruptcy they still have ample resources to hire the best and brightest attorneys to litigate the claims against them. Every dollar the Sacklers spend on attorneys is one dollar less that could be paid to opioid victims. Not only would getting a judgment for a personal injury claim against any of the Sacklers be an uphill battle, but enforcing that judgment would be difficult, as the Sacklers have many assets that are not subject to easy collection—for example, the assets are overseas. A judgment without means to enforce it is worth about as much as the paper on which it is printed. The unpleasant reality is that securing the Sacklers’ participation through Purdue Pharma’s bankruptcy reorganization may be the most efficient way to get funds to the families and individuals that have suffered harm as a result of the aggressive marketing of dangerously addictive opioids. A Dangerous Precedent No matter what the final outcome of the Sackler appeal is, it will have
7 + 13 = 10: The CBRA’s Huge Proposals to Change Consumer Bankruptcy

When a consumer is facing bankruptcy, many are given the choice between Chapter 7 and Chapter 13. While some consumers have successful bankruptcies under these chapters, these gloves don’t fit many financially distressed consumers. The Consumer Bankruptcy Reform Act (CBRA) was introduced to streamline consumer bankruptcy and provide more consumers with the opportunity to receive a discharge. The CBRA was introduced as a 188-page bill with many provisions addressing a variety of areas of bankruptcy reform., Most significantly, the bill consolidates Chapter 7 for individuals and Chapter 13 into a new Chapter 10. Chapter 10 Single-Track System Chapter 7 offers consumers the chance to liquidate their non-exempt assets in exchange for a discharge, while Chapter 13 allows a consumer to make payments over the course of a three- to five-year plan. The CBRA would make individuals ineligible for Chapter 7 and would repeal Chapter 13. All individuals with assets worth less than $7.5 million are instead eligible for Chapter 10 bankruptcy. Individuals with assets over $7.5 million would be required to file for Chapter 11, or 12 if eligible. Chapter 10 acts like a hybrid of Chapter 7 and 13 but is meant to completely replace both. Consumer flexibility was one of the bill authors’ primary concerns when drafting the CBRA. While a consumer may have a choice between Chapter 7 and 13, that choice is often meaningless. Chapter 7 does not allow attorney’s fees to be paid through liquidation of estate assets. In effect, this makes many individuals too poor to file for Chapter 7. This pushes consumers to Chapter 13, which is more expensive, and it is less likely the debtor will receive a discharge because many debtor’s plans fail. Moreover, the “means test” is another barrier to Chapter 7 relief that forces consumers into a Chapter 13 plan. The single-track system proposed by the CBRA prevents this bifurcation by putting all consumers in the same Chapter 10 pool. Chapter 10 looks to a debtor’s nonexempt assets and future income simultaneously, instead of the current approach in which Chapter 7 looks at nonexempt assets, and Chapter 13 looks to future disposable income. In a Chapter 10 bankruptcy, the debtor is no longer confronted with the difficult choice of choosing whether to liquidate assets but retain their future income under a Chapter 7 or to keep all their assets while paying their disposable income to creditors throughout a Chapter 13 plan. Significantly, Chapter 10 does not consider a debtor’s expenses like a Chapter 13 does, so a debtor will not have to justify expenses to the bankruptcy court. How to Receive a Discharge Under Chapter 10 Under Chapter 10, a debtor must pay a “minimum payment obligation” equal to the sum of the debtor’s nonexempt assets and a graduated percentage of the debtor’s annual income exceeding 135% of the state median income for a household of the same size. The goal of this minimum payment obligation requirement is to quickly separate debtors who can pay and debtors who cannot. Thus, if a debtor’s minimum payment obligation is zero, the debtor is eligible for an immediate discharge of all dischargeable unsecured debts, much like a Chapter 7 currently, whereas debtors with a non-zero minimum payment obligation will receive a discharge upon confirmation of a repayment plan. If a debtor can pay a minimum payment obligation, they must create a repayment plan to repay their creditors over the course of at least a three-year plan. This plan can be paid by using a combination of future income, exempt assets, and nonexempt assets. Distributions are made according to the same priority levels of 11 U.S.C. § 726, but there is no requirement that priority claims be paid in full. Chapter 10 also gives flexibility to a debtor who cannot pay the minimum payment obligation if they are justifiably excused for “circumstances the debtor cannot reasonably avoid.” Creditors are given some protection by allowing them to request the case be dismissed, but the CBRA removes the judge-created “substantial abuse” standard, allowing a creditor to have a case dismissed only if the debtor engaged in a “manifestly improper use of the bankruptcy system.” It is unclear, what the difference is between these two standards, but it seems clear that the drafters are intentionally rebuking the “substantial abuse” language. The bankruptcy court must confirm any feasible plan that is not proposed in bad faith and covers court fees, so long as the debtor current on their domestic support obligations incurred post-petition. If the plan is proposed without any objections, then it will be confirmed immediately without a hearing. This is another example of the CBRA’s commitment to expediting the bankruptcy process for consumers to reduce costs. One of the most significant changes under Chapter 10, is that a debtor receives a discharge immediately upon plan confirmation. Under Chapter 13, a debtor receives a discharge only after completing their plan, which debtors often fail to do. Chapter 10 drastically changes the supervision of the bankruptcy court over the life of a plan, making the trustee responsible for enforcing the debtor’s bankruptcy obligations. The trustee does this through liens on the debtor’s nonexempt assets. A default on the plan does not revoke the discharge like under Chapter 13, and Chapter 10 provides the debtor with more flexibility to modify their plan because of changing financial conditions. What About Secured Debt? Secured debt is handled under separate “property” and “residence” plans. These plans allow a debtor to change the terms of their obligations but by themselves do not result in a discharge. This allows for a debtor to file a “limited” bankruptcy to address falling behind on a mortgage or car loan without having to bring all the debtor’s other creditors into court. However, a combination of a repayment plan and a property or residence plan can lead to a discharge, and there is still an immediate discharge for a debtor whose minimum payment obligation is zero. Property and residence plans give the debtor the option to adjust interest
Chapter 12 Bankruptcy Rules of Engagement: Farming Operation or Not?

Relief for Farmers Prior to 1986, a debtor intending to reorganize debts had two options for filing for bankruptcy: Chapter 11 or Chapter 13. Unfortunately, neither option was particularly well suited for family farmers. Chapter 11 provided a complicated and expensive route to relief, while Chapter 13 lent itself to reorganizing debt loads much lower than those often carried by farmers. Congress recognized the need for a more streamlined process for “family farmers” and “family fishermen,” and thus, Chapter 12 Bankruptcy was born, combining provisions already included in the Bankruptcy Code into a new structure that allowed farmers to continue owning and operating the farm while repaying all or part of their debts. Along with restrictions regarding the source and amounts of debt and income, the Bankruptcy Code requires that a petitioner be “engaged in a farming operation” to be eligible to file under Chapter 12. In spite of this limitation, farmers who have ceased the physical activity of farming but seek to file under this chapter may still have hope. In re Mongeau, recently decided in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Kansas, provides some guidance. Mongeau Case Study David and Jennifer Mongeau jointly owned and operated a large farming operation where they grew crops and ran cattle. As all too often happens with farming operations, what was once a profitable endeavor became much less so. The Mongeaus made the decision to complete a structured wind-down and began liquidating their farm assets in 2020. By the end of the year, they had ceased the vast majority of their farming activities and sold or otherwise transferred most property and leases to others. Notably, the Mongeaus’ family members purchased much of the real property and equipment, and that family members used the same equipment and the leases David and Jennifer had previously held in the family members’ operations. David and Jennifer continued to provide manual labor in helping on their family members’ farms despite winding down their own operations. On February 1, 2021, the Mongeaus filed their Chapter 12 petition. An unsecured creditor, American AgCredit, moved to dismiss the bankruptcy, claiming that the Mongeaus failed to meet the Code’s definition of being “engaged in a farming operation” and therefore were not entitled to file under Chapter 12. The Bankruptcy Court disagreed. As there was no dispute over the other Chapter 12 eligibility requirements, the Court looked only at whether the debtors were engaged in a farming operation on the date of filing. After discussing tests utilized by other jurisdictions and considering factors proposed by the parties based on relevant case law, the Court weighed five factors to determine whether the Mongeaus were engaged in a farming operation: (1) whether the debtors had abandoned all farming operations at the time of filing; (2) whether there was a plan or intent to continue farming operations in some form; (3) whether the abandonment of farming was a shift to a different type of farming; (4) whether debtors own farm assets such as equipment; and (5) whether the activities are subject to the cyclical risks involved in farming. The outcome of the factor test was determined by looking at the totality of the circumstances on a case-by-case basis. In evaluating the first factor, the Court looked beyond the narrow interpretation proposed by AgCredit and found ample evidence that the Mongeaus’ had not abandoned all farming operations. The debtors’ continued involvement in family members’ farms, care of their daughter’s cattle, and partial ownership of cattle equipment intended to be used in a future smaller scale livestock operation supported the Court’s finding. Beyond that, the Court also gave significant value to the business side of farming, noting that “managing the business elements of a farm are just as much farming as plowing the ground.” David Mongeau was still actively engaged in the business side of farming beyond the date of filing, as he continued to distribute their 2020 farm income to creditors as it came in from various sources. The Court spent less time discussing the other four factors. It evaluated the second and third together and found that the Mongeaus’ testimony regarding their intent to start a smaller-scale cattle operation with their brother, coupled with the concrete evidence provided by their involvement in the family farms and partial ownership of cattle equipment, showed a legitimate intent to continue farming of a different type. The Court looked to the debtors’ current ownership of a pickup, cattle equipment, and funds that arose from the sale of equipment and crops to satisfy the fourth element, and finally, the fact that the Mongeaus were “winding up the results of the risks previously taken” was enough to satisfy the fifth factor. After considering all of the circumstances surrounding the Mongeaus’ situation, the Court found that the Mongeaus were engaged in a farming operation when they filed their Chapter 12 petition, and were therefore eligible to be Chapter 12 debtors. Application Though the Court cautions that this case should not be taken as an endorsement of the Mongeaus’ methods, it does serve as an example of how farmers who have ceased the physical activity of farming may successfully establish that they are “engaged in a farming operation” and, by extension, Chapter 12 eligibility. The Court’s focus on Congress’s intent to help family farmers to continue farming and willingness to consider all facets of farming, not just working the ground or raising animals, leaves room for debtors to prove what activities constitute farming in their operation. As the Court points out, the inclusion of the simple word “farming” in the list of activities that satisfy the definition of “farming operation” allows for consideration of modernization and the changing processes that come along with it. As with any court case, supporting evidence is crucial. To have the best chance at success, a filer attempting to meet their burden of proof in establishing Chapter 12 eligibility after ceasing some or even all physical farming activities should not only be prepared to give testimony regarding their previous
Creditor Attorney Fees in Bankruptcy

In bankruptcy, parties fight over a limited pool of assets while fees diminish what remains in the estate. While most creditors are responsible for paying their own attorneys’ fees, oversecured creditors are entitled to attorney fees from the debtor pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 506(b) which states: To the extent that an allowed secured claim is secured by property the value of which, after any recovery under subsection (c) of this section, is greater than the amount of such claim, there shall be allowed to the holder of such claim … any reasonable fees … provided for under the agreement or State statute under which such claim arose. 11 U.S.C. § 506(b) https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/11/506 Section 506(b) establishes three rules applied when the bankruptcy court looks at creditor attorney fees. “To recover attorneys’ fees, a creditor must establish that: (1) it is oversecured in excess of the fees requested, (2) the fees are reasonable; and (3) the agreement giving rise to the claim provides for attorneys’ fees.” In re White, 260 B.R. 870, 880 (B.A.P. 8th Cir. 2001). The most fact-intensive inquiry of this three-pronged test is the reasonableness prong, requiring the court to consider a variety of factors specific to the case at bar that would justify the proposed creditor attorneys’ fees. In re Kurtenbach In re Kurtenbach, a 2020 case in the Northern District of Iowa, presented the bankruptcy court with the issue of whether a creditor’s attorney fees were reasonable in this complicated Chapter 12 case. The court considered factors such as the complexity of the case, the hourly rates charged, whether the services were necessary for the client, whether the attorneys efficiently and competently provided their services, whether billing judgment was exercised, the results obtained, and amounts charged in similar cases. Facts Farm Credit, the oversecured creditor in this case, sought creditor attorneys’ fees amounting to $219,447.67. The debtor objected to these fees, admitting that Farm Credit was eligible for attorneys’ fees under § 506(b) but claiming the amount requested was unreasonable. Farm Credit responded by claiming that the complex case warranted a greater amount of work, especially because of the debtor’s multiple plan proposals. Through the course of the Chapter 12 case, there were four different bankruptcy plans proposed by the debtor. Farm Credit objected to each of them. Additionally, the proposed plans were “a bit out of the ordinary.” Then, confirmation hearings on these proposed plans were rescheduled repeatedly. Ultimately, the case presented far more work for debtor’s counsel and Farm Credit’s counsel than the average Chapter 12 case. Discussion The courts have broad discussion to review attorney fee applications, including those from creditors’ attorneys. The court first looked at the complexity of the case and acknowledged that the case’s complexity supported a claim for a large fee but also said that complexity is not dispositive. The court also recognized that the hourly rate charged by Farm Credit’s attorneys was reasonable. The court then looked to whether the fees were necessary to protect Farm Credit’s interest. Farm Credit sought to recover fees for a motion for relief of stay, and the court determined that this was not necessary for the interests of Farm Credit because Farm Credit’s status as an oversecured creditor made relief of stay highly unlikely. Thus, the court reduced $6,000 worth of fees for services relating to the motion for relief of stay. The bulk of the court’s discussion related to the efficiency of the services and whether billing judgment was exercised. The court found multiple instances of Farm Credit’s attorneys billing for services that did not meet the efficiency requirement. Farm Credit’s attorneys billed for reviewing documents, exhibits, and witness lists each time the debtor proposed a new plan, even though these items were essentially the same for each plan proposal. While the court admitted that there may be additional services that would need to be billed for each proposed plan, the court found that the extent of services rendered seemed far too great in many instances. Moreover, when the court Farm Credit’s attorneys exercised billing judgment, it found multiple instances of duplicative services. The court found examples of attorneys billing for reading, reviewing, drafting, and revising the same documents multiple times. Although the court recognized that diligence is necessary for good lawyering, the court pointed out that diligence must be reasonable. In this case that diligence was not reasonable. Because Farm Credit failed to eliminate duplicative billing entries or explain the confusion surrounding it, the court had to adjust fees accordingly. The court recognized that Farm Credit’s attorneys had produced favorable results for their clients, which weighed in favor of a fee award, and then turned to whether the fees Farm Credit sought could be compared to any similar cases. The court pointed out that the case was unique, and the best comparison would be to compare the fees charged by Farm Credit’s attorneys to the fees charged by debtor’s counsel in this case. This point presents an interesting observation that appears to undergird the opinion. Debtor’s counsel presented the argument that Farm Credit’s attorneys’ fees should not exceed the estimated $160,000 of fees requested by debtor’s counsel in this case. The court recognized that debtor’s counsel’s fee requests were familiar to the court and the court consistently approved them. The court further states, “Debtor’s counsel’s fees provide at least a general benchmark for the amount and value of services required in this unusual case.” The court does not appear to say that counsel for an oversecured creditor can never charge more than debtor’s counsel, but rather, in this case, the court could appropriately compare fees between the oversecured creditor’s counsel and debtor’s counsel to determine reasonableness. This is a clever approach by Chief Bankruptcy Judge Thad Collins because the court was familiar with both firms and the case was so unusual. Critics may claim that this decision penalizes the creditor’s attorneys for being diligent, but this concern is overstated. An oversecured creditor must be able to justify their attorney’s billing to the bankruptcy court just as that
Chapter 12 Bankruptcy: Is It Right for Me?

The decision to file bankruptcy is not one that is made lightly. By the time the petition is filed, there have likely been many difficult conversations and strategy sessions to make sure that the entity or individual is making the best move for the future. An essential part of that strategy involves considering the goals of the debtor and deciding whether to liquidate assets to pay off debts or to reorganize and repay debt with the hope of continuing to operate their farm or business after the bankruptcy. For farmers* looking to continue operating after a bankruptcy discharge is granted, Chapter 12 bankruptcy is an enticing option, as it offers unique benefits to those who qualify, but it is important to evaluate whether it is really the best choice. Who Qualifies? Chapter 12 bankruptcy was created to specifically apply to “family farmers” with regular annual income. By requiring that the debtor have regular income, Chapter 12 lends itself to debtors that are better able to make plan payments while figuring out how to successfully continue farming. To meet the definition of family farmer, individuals and business organizations must show that they meet specific criteria laid out in the Bankruptcy Code. Individuals must: (1) be engaged in a farming operation; (2) be carrying less than $11,097,350 in debt; (3) have at least 50 percent of that debt from a farming operation that they own and operate; and (4) have more than 50 percent of the individual’s (or the individual’s and the individual’s spouse’s) gross income come from farming in the tax year directly before filing or each of the second and third years preceding the tax year in which the bankruptcy case is filed.[i] Bankruptcy courts have indicated some flexibility with what constitutes engagement in a farming operation,[ii] but that is the only factor that allows for much flexibility of interpretation. Corporations or partnerships may also file “farm bankruptcy,” but they must meet even more criteria to avail themselves to Chapter 12’s protections. In addition to the regular income requirement, on the date of filing, a corporation or partnership must: (1) have more than 50 percent of the outstanding stock or equity held by one family or by one family and its relatives; (2) have the majority owner family conducting the farming; (3) have more than 80 percent of the corporation’s or partnership’s assets be related to the farming operation; (4) have aggregate debts of no more than $11,097,350; (5) at least 50 percent of the debt must be attributable to the farming operation; and (6) the corporation must not issue publicly traded stock.[iii] Once debtors clear the eligibility hurdle, they should assess whether the benefits of Chapter 12 bankruptcy make it the best strategic choice. Benefits Family farmers that want to continue their operation while repaying some or all of their debts may find the unique provisions of Chapter 12 bankruptcy extremely helpful in achieving that goal. Because farm income is inherently seasonal, farm debtors may struggle to make consistent monthly payments as required by other forms of bankruptcy. Chapter 12 allows the reorganization plan to provide for payments scheduled around harvest and typical commodity marketing times, and that plan may be confirmed even over the objections of creditors, so long as the court deems it acceptable. Farm debtors may also find value in Chapter 12’s allowance for the sale of farmland or farm equipment free and clear of creditor’s interest where other types of bankruptcy severely limit that sale. Selling that land and equipment inevitably creates tax consequences that must be handled by the bankruptcy estate. Where Chapter 11 requires that the capital gains tax is paid in full as a priority claim, Chapter 12 pushes that capital gains tax liability to the back of the priority line where it may be discharged, either in full or in part, after completion of the plan.[iv] Being able to “right size” the operation without incurring a crippling tax bill increases the likelihood that a debtor will be able to successfully complete the reorganization plan, receive a discharge of the remaining debts, and continue farming after completion of the bankruptcy. Finally, Chapter 12 debtors have the privilege to use “cramdown” on any secured debt. Cramdown makes it so that creditors only receive the present market value of the property used to secure the debt rather than the full amount owed. Debtors who are currently “upside down” on assets can find significant relief in this provision. Reality Check Even if a debtor qualifies for Chapter 12 bankruptcy and the benefits would serve them well, it still may not be the best option for relief. The unfortunate reality is that from 2000 to 2015, less than half of Chapter 12 debtors were able to successfully complete all plan payments and receive a discharge of the remaining debts.[v] A debtor whose current cash-flow left them unable to make timely payment of their debts, necessitating a bankruptcy filing, needs to seriously consider whether they can realistically make plan payments while continuing to run their operation as they have been. Though the provisions of Chapter 12 allow for downsizing or changing the type of farming operation, careful consideration should be given to whether attempting to restructure is just postponing the inevitable liquidation of the assets. Having a team of knowledgeable and trustworthy advisors, both personal and professional, is invaluable when making such a pivotal decision. By considering the eligibility requirements, the benefits offered, and the feasibility of a debt reorganization plan, debtors can make an informed decision on whether Chapter 12 bankruptcy is right for them. *Note: Chapter 12 bankruptcy also applies to family fishermen, but this post only addresses farm bankruptcy. This article was updated to reflect that as of April 1, 2022, the chapter 12 bankruptcy debt limit was increased from $10,000,000 to $11,097,350. Sources Thriving After a Farm Bankruptcy Fact Sheet, https://28xeuf2otxva18q7lx1uemec-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/wp-content/uploads/assets/articles/bankruptcy/Thriving-after-a-farm-bankruptcy.pdf https://www.calt.iastate.edu/article/review-farm-bankruptcy [i] 11 U.S.C. § 101(18)(A) [ii] In re Mongeau, No. 21-40055, 2021 Bankr. LEXIS 2923 (Bankr. D. Kan. Oct. 22, 2021) [iii] 11 U.S.C. § 101(18)(B) [iv] McEowen, Roger, Farm
Sub V: Sub-par or Superb?

Subchapter V (“Sub V”) of the Bankruptcy Code was created under the Small Business Reorganization Act (P.L. 116-54) to streamline bankruptcy cases and help more small business debtors successfully reorganize by lowering costs. Sub V was meant to strike a balance between Chapter 7 liquidation and Chapter 11 reorganization. Sub V created some significant benefits for debtors compared to previous options under Chapter 11 but also comes with some eligibility and plan requirements (some might say burdens) for interested debtors. Eligibility The SBRA became effective February 19, 2020, and shortly thereafter, the COVID-19 panic spurred Congress to increase the debt limit for Sub V from $2.7 million to $7.5 million. However, the debt limit is to return to its original level in March of 2022 unless Congress chooses to act “(July 2024 update: in 2022 Congress did act, belatedly extending the increased Subchapter V debt limit for two more years. However, this extension expired on June 21, 2024 without any further Congressional action. The current Subchapter V debt limit is $3,024,725. Ag & Business Legal Strategies, along with the American Bankruptcy Institute and other organizations, supports reverting the Subchapter V debt limit to $7.5 million.)”. This debt limit only applies when the majority of the debt stems from business or commercial activity. Individuals can be eligible under Sub V if their debts are business-related, but the act primarily applies to small business debtors. Moreover, debtors who meet the Bankruptcy Code’s definition of “single asset real estate” are explicitly excluded from Sub V eligibility. Mandatory Trustee Sub V creates the position of a mandatory trustee to oversee the administration of the bankruptcy case. This trustee performs duties similar to Chapter 12 trustees, supervising the case while the debtor remains in control of their business operations. The trustee is intended to assist the debtor with their plan proposal, confirmation, and distributions. Furthermore, the Sub V trustee examines proof of claims and objects to improper claims. The Sub V trustee also retains standing to oppose the discharge when he or she chooses. Uniquely, Sub V trustees are meant to help facilitate a consensual reorganization plan and assist the debtor in guiding the business. Therefore, many Sub V trustees are businesspeople rather than lawyers. Plan Requirements Sub V has an accelerated timeline, including a status conference within sixty days of the order of relief. Debtors must file a reorganization plan in ninety days. However, debtors can obtain an extension of this deadline by requesting the court and showing that a plan could not be filed for circumstances beyond the control of the debtor. Experience has shown Sub V cases take longer than Congress expected. Courts often grant extensions beyond the ninety-day period. For example, in the 8th Circuit, the average time taken for a debtor to confirm a plan was about seven months. It appears the accelerated timeline of Sub V is more of a nominal requirement which may encourage the debtor to act quickly but from which courts have routinely relieved debtors upon request. Sub V debtors must commit future projected income or its equivalent value (attained through the liquidation of estate assets) to the plan for a designated period of time. This is similar to the disposable income requirements of Chapters 12 and 13, and like in those chapters, the length of this period can range from three to five years. This requirement under Sub V presents less flexibility to the debtor than under traditional Chapter 11, and it presents the issue of determining projected disposable income despite that a business debtor’s disposable income may fluctuate greatly before filing bankruptcy. Benefits One of the biggest goals of Sub V was to reduce costs for the debtor, as traditional Chapter 11s are notoriously expensive. First, Sub V waives the U.S. Trustee’s fees otherwise required of Chapter 11 debtors, requiring instead that debtors pay the Sub V trustee’s fees. This is combined with an expectation that Sub V trustees generally will not incur much in fees. Second, Sub V does away with the establishment of a committee of creditors in almost all cases. This is significant because a debtor in a traditional Chapter 11 is responsible for paying professionals hired by the committee. Third, the debtor does not have to file a disclosure statement when filing under Sub V. A disclosure statement is necessary in traditional Chapter 11 plans to inform creditors of key provisions of the plan so that the creditors are able to vote on the proposed plan and potentially propose their own competing plans. However, under Sub V creditors can only object to a plan, like in a Chapter 12 or 13, rather than vote on it, like in a traditional Chapter 11, and the debtor is the only one who can propose a plan. This eliminates the costs of bankruptcy litigation when competing plans go before the court. Lastly, Sub V generally relaxes the requirements debtors face when drafting a plan. The plan must be nondiscriminatory and fair and equitable, but so long as the plan meets the Bankruptcy Code’s requirements, the court is likely to approve it. In addition to reducing costs for debtors, Sub V allows owners of a debtor business to retain ownership without either paying all creditors in full or contributing new value to the business (in bankruptcy-speak, Sub V eliminates the absolute priority rule, which eliminates any fights about the new value exception). This allows a small business owner to reorganize the business, reduce debt, and maintain ownership. Since in small businesses ownership and management are often the same or have significant overlap, this helps preserve the business’s going-concern value. How has it worked? Sub V is very new, and much of the legal questions that have arisen from Sub V cases have yet to be completely resolved. However, data suggests that Sub V has become a popular choice for small business debtors. Nationwide about 23% of all Chapter 11 cases filed in 2020 were filed as Sub V cases, and between March 1,
Terminating the Technicality: Venue Reform, Why It’s Important, and What You Can Do About It

Bankruptcy is a legislative creation aimed at giving debtors the opportunity for a fresh start while still recognizing the rights of their creditors to be paid. Chapter 11 Bankruptcy allows an entity experiencing financial distress, typically a corporation or partnership, to seek relief through reorganization, while retaining their business in hopes of generating revenue to pay debts as completely as possible. The debtor first files its bankruptcy petition and proposes a plan for repayment. Creditors are given the opportunity to vote on whether the plan is acceptable, and after considering those votes, the court may or may not confirm the plan. The expectation is that a company will file bankruptcy where it is actually located. Unfortunately, many large companies have found a way to circumvent the statutory requirements and file in a jurisdiction with which they have no meaningful connection in hopes of obtaining a more favorable outcome. The Technicality The current law requires an entity to file its bankruptcy in one of two places: (1) the district where the entity’s place of incorporation, residence, principal place of business, or principal assets in the United States have been located for at least 180 days or (2) the district where an affiliate of the entity has a pending bankruptcy matter. The second option is where companies found an opportunity for creativity. Say Company X wants to file bankruptcy in front of a judge who is historically more likely to accept its arguments. By setting up a subsidiary in that judge’s district, having that subsidiary guarantee the debts of the already-struggling company, and then having the subsidiary file for bankruptcy, Company X suddenly has an affiliate with a pending bankruptcy matter there, albeit a manufactured one. Company X is then legally entitled to file its bankruptcy petition in that judge’s district and potentially have its plan confirmed when other judges would have declined. Purdue Pharma’s Filing In re Purdue Pharma, L.P. is a textbook case of this tactic. Opioid manufacturer Purdue Pharma sought to use bankruptcy as a mechanism to compel acceptance of a global settlement by the plaintiffs in numerous civil actions brought against it and various members of the Sackler family who indirectly owned the corporation, as those were the company’s only major creditors. Among other things, its reorganization plan included what is known as a third-party release, which would shield the Sackler family from liability relating to Purdue’s role in the opioid crisis. Bankruptcy courts are split over whether third-party releases are an appropriate inclusion in reorganization plans, and those that allow them do so on a very limited basis. Appearing in front of the “right” judge in the “right” jurisdiction is paramount. Purdue recognized an opportunity and worked to get its matter into the Southern District of New York in front of the Honorable Judge Robert D. Drain, who had previously indicated an openness to entering a third-party release as part of a Chapter 11 reorganization plan. Over multiple creditor objections, Judge Drain approved Purdue’s reorganization plan, including the third-party release that protects the Sacklers from current and future litigation relating to the opioid epidemic. The bankruptcy plan sets aside funds for programs to be established by cities, counties, and other entities, as well as money to be paid to individuals affected by opioids after an adjudication process. However, holding members of the Sackler family liable for their role is no longer an available avenue. In exchange for paying a fraction of their estimated personal profits from the opioid epidemic over nearly a decade, the Sacklers have immunized themselves from further liability, despite objections from those harmed by the opioid epidemic. Exploitation The creative maneuvering employed by these companies, known as “forum shopping”, is an exploitation of flexibility purposefully built into the bankruptcy venue statute by its drafters, and Purdue is not alone in the practice. When the statute was adopted back in 1974, the committee fully expected that allowing companies multiple options for choice of venue would get the cases placed in the most appropriate court. This expectation rested on a belief that judges who found bankruptcy cases filed in their courts without a meaningful connection to the district would kick those cases to the court where it should have been originally filed “in the interest of justice or for the convenience of the parties” as they are authorized to do under 28 U.S. Code § 1412. The unfortunate reality is that judges tend not to exercise that discretion, and even if they do it often doesn’t occur until many of the most important decisions in the case have been made and after significant expenditures of money and effort by objectors. These realities only serve to encourage forum shopping. Termination Current legislation takes aim at closing the loophole and strengthening the integrity of the bankruptcy system while increasing public confidence and fairness. The Bankruptcy Venue Reform Act of 2021 (H.R. 4193), introduced in June of 2021, and the identical Senate bill (S.2827), introduced in September of 2021, acknowledge the practice of forum shopping and the resulting concentration of bankruptcy cases into just a few districts. The bill’s text also notes that not only does forum shopping prevent important stakeholders from fully participating in the bankruptcy process, it removes the possibility of the unchosen district participating meaningfully in the development of the bankruptcy law that will inevitably affect its constituents. In hopes of removing the enticement to forum shop, H.R. 4193 and S.2827 propose to add significantly more detail to the venue statute. Along with formatting changes that would make the statute more readable, the legislation includes important changes, including: specifically defining the term “principal place of business”; significantly limiting the option to file in a district where an affiliate has a case pending; placing the burden of proving correct venue on the entity that files the bankruptcy; and requiring cases filed in an improper venue be either dismissed or moved to the appropriate district rather than leaving it to the judge’s discretion. Leaving limited room for interpretation
A Call for Bankruptcy Venue Reform

In February of 2021, Belk, a North Carolina department-store chain, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the United States Bankruptcy Court of the Southern District of Texas. After the large retail company with over 90,000 creditors filed on the evening of February 23rd, their plan was confirmed and consummated by the end of the next day. The U.S. Trustee, the Department of Justice’s bankruptcy watchdog, was quick to object to the plan’s confirmation with the understandable concern that about 90,000 creditors would be swindled of their Due Process rights by not being notified prior to plan confirmation. The bankruptcy court appeared to think little of these concerns and granted a toothless 35-day objection period. It was clear to the parties involved that the case was over upon consummation, and Belk’s bankruptcy would sweep through the court before most of their creditors could even blink. Through the rapid administration of this case, the court ignored basic elements of bankruptcy rules and procedure, and the rights of creditors were relegated to an afterthought. Unfortunately, Belk’s bankruptcy is not unlike other Chapter 11 cases. Many courts have been willing to bend the Bankruptcy Code in large Chapter 11s to the whims of the debtors’ executives, debtors’ counsel, and debtor-in-possession lenders who often finance the bankruptcy. These judges have engaged in this Bankruptcy Code puppeteering to compete for large Chapter 11 cases to be filed in their court, and because of flexible bankruptcy venue laws, debtors can easily flock to the courts where the judges will be the most pliable. A Case Study Consider how Belk, a North Carolina company, was able to file in the Southern District of Texas. The current bankruptcy venue statute, 28 U.S.C. § 1408 allows a debtor to file in the district “in which the domicile, residence, principal place of business in the United States, or principle assets in the United States” of the debtor are located. However, the debtor cannot just move from one district to another and file immediately; the statute requires the debtor to be eligible for over 180 days in the district. The issue is that the statute has a built-in exception that allows large companies to file virtually anywhere. Section 1408(2) allows the debtor to file anywhere “in which there is a pending [bankruptcy] case … concerning such [debtor’s] affiliate.” This is how Belk made it to the Southern District of Texas. Belk had subsidiaries file in the Southern District of Texas, and the affiliates’ bankruptcies acted as a venue “hook” to allow Belk to file in the Southern District of Texas. Concerningly, the court did not even appear to accurately apply the existing venue statute, because Belk never showed that any of these affiliates were eligible in the Southern District of Texas either. Regardless, the result was a bankruptcy case that did not belong in the Southern District of Texas being administered expeditiously by a judge who chose to abdicate his duties of enforcing the bankruptcy code in exchange for bolstering the court’s reputation as a Chapter 11 destination. Incentives for Shady Venue Practices Under the current bankruptcy venue statute, two incentives combine for disastrous results. First, debtors and their case managers are incentivized with their broad discretion to maneuver Chapter 11 cases to the judges that will bend to their will. Second, some judges are incentivized to either violate the law or manipulate it to attract glamorous Chapter 11 cases. These incentives have produced a competition over what court or judge can give results most favorable to bankruptcy case placers (most often debtor’s attorneys and financiers for bankruptcy debtors). Currently, five bankruptcy courts that hear more than 90% of the bankruptcy cases in the United States – Houston, Delaware, White Plains, Richmond, and New York. This is enormous control in the hands of very few judges. Even worse, large companies and their attorneys are sometimes able to choose the specific judge that will administer the case by manipulating local bankruptcy court rules. The Argument for Reform The solution is bankruptcy venue reform. On June 28, 2021, H.R. 4193, the Bankruptcy Venue Reform Act of 2021, was introduced in the House as a bipartisan solution, and a substantively identical reform act was introduced in the Senate as S.2827 on September 23, 2021. The Act limits the ability of large companies to forum shop by requiring that the debtor file where its headquarters or principal assets are located. Moreover, it puts the burden on the debtor to show by “clear and convincing” evidence that the venue selected is proper under the act. This would prevent large companies from filing wherever they please and thus would eliminate incentives for bankruptcy judges to cow tow to the demands of large corporations and their financiers. It is easy to see why state attorneys general as well as bankruptcy professionals and scholars are calling for venue reform but make no mistake, this issue has broad ramifications. Look no further than Purdue Pharma’s Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Purdue Pharma, though based in Connecticut, was able to pick the court and even the judge for its bankruptcy. Exploiting the flexibility of the current venue statute, Purdue Pharma was able to file in the Southern District of New York. Even worse, Purdue was able to select their judge by using a local rule that made Judge Robert Drain the only possible bankruptcy judge for the case. This was exactly as Purdue Pharma’s owners had planned. Purdue Pharma and its owners, the Sackler family, had been implicated in the opioid crisis. Judge Drain approved a plan that shielded the Sackler family from liability in future opioid-related cases even though none of the Sacklers had personally filed for bankruptcy. In response to Judge Drain’s questionable decisions, Connecticut’s Attorney General, William Tong, said “[the Sacklers] should not be able to manipulate bankruptcy laws to evade justice and protect their blood money.” Essentially, Judge Drain, through bankruptcy, eliminated the rights of opioid victims to recover potentially billions of dollars in damages. Contact your Elected Officials!
Thirty-Three Years of Asking, “Are We There Yet?”

The Commercial Law League of America recently published Joe Peiffer’s article “Thirty-Three Years of Asking “Are We There Yet?”” as one of the title articles in the summer edition of their publication, Commercial Law World. Click the image below to read the article. **As of April 1, 2022 the chapter 12 bankruptcy debt limit has increased to $11,097,350.
