Skip to main content

Ag & Business Legal Strategies

Death and Taxes is How We Lose It: The Importance of Succession Planning for American Agriculture

Wood figures representing people, titled Succession Planning

The hit TV show “Yellowstone” has achieved popularity with agricultural and non-agricultural audiences alike. Along with dramatized glimpses of ranching life, it also provides nuggets of truth with real world application. In a recent episode, while facilitating the sale of a family farm where one sibling couldn’t afford to buy the other out to retain the ranch, a real estate agent simply stated “Horses and cattle may be how the West was won, but death and taxes is how we’re gonna lose it.” Though that is certainly an oversimplification, the fact remains that failing to plan for the transition of a farm or ranch to future generations, and the tax consequences of those transfers, can result in the forced sale of some or all of the operation, many times to someone outside the agriculture field. Making a plan for the future can be intimidating, as it involves confronting mortality and making business decisions intertwined with family dynamics. Fortunately, there are steps that producers can take and resources available to make the process less overwhelming. Step 1 – Know What Makes Up a Succession Plan A common misconception is that succession planning is just a different term for estate planning. In reality, estate planning is just a portion of the process that works alongside a comprehensive plan to move the operation from one generation to the next, including the transition of decision-making power and the management and work responsibilities of the operation. In order to facilitate a successful shift, a succession plan typically includes steps that develop the next generation’s knowledge and participation in the operation, making it important to begin planning as soon as there is an indication that the next generation is interested in taking over when the current generation is ready. A thorough plan will consider the strengths and weaknesses of each of the parties to the transition, goals for the operation’s future, and potential threats or obstacles to the operation’s success. The key ingredient for a succession plan is detail, as it reduces the risk of misunderstanding, so the more that can be put in writing, the better. Step 2 – Know the Specifics of Your Operation Familiarity with one’s operation includes both quantitative and qualitative aspects. It is important for everyone involved to know the status of the operation’s finances and resources. This allows the feasibility of future operations to be assessed and also provides clarity for the successor about the situation into which they will be stepping. An accurate inventory of all resources, including tangible assets, support services, and people willing to assist is important information to flesh out the assessment. State extension programs can provide assistance in analyzing these values to gain an even better long-range picture and develop a financial plan. The qualitative specifics are more individually based and require some introspection and honesty from the parties. Each person involved in the transition should work to clearly identify their own wants and needs for the operation before sharing that information with other family members. In doing so, they will likely avoid some of the difficulty that may come from trying to voice opinions about the future of the operation and wanting to avoid “stepping on toes.” Individuals should also be aware of the strengths and weaknesses they bring to the transition and whether those characteristics lend themselves to continuing the same operation procedures or whether a change is in order. Once those individual visions and assessments are complete, all stakeholders should work together to create a central vision statement around which the succession plan will be formed. Step 3 – Formulate a Plan Once the broader vision statement is established, focus can shift to creating more specific objectives and goals that achieve that vision, while factoring in the inventory of resources available. Feasibility, attainability, and timeliness are necessary considerations when forming these goals and objectives and must remain a priority throughout the planning process. A business plan incorporates all of the stakeholder-established goals and objectives into one comprehensive plan that shows forethought and reliability to both internal clients, like family members and employees, and external clients, like lenders, investors, and partners. It should lay out the management structure of the operation, as well as the legal and financial structure of the business. Here again, state extension programs can provide resources to help develop an agricultural business plan, and the assistance of a skilled attorney can be invaluable. Once a business plan is nailed down, the focus can finally shift to estate planning and retirement planning. The chosen legal structure and financial structure of the business can affect the transferability of assets, distribution of income, and how the income and estate is taxed. The laws that govern these things are ever-changing, so here again, a skilled attorney is worth their weight in gold to not only establish initial positions that are favorable to the stakeholders but also to adapt the plan to changing laws to make sure that the succession plan continues to accomplish the intended outcomes.   Step 4 – Implement the Plan Finally, a timeline must be established for implementing the changes laid out in the succession plan. Though the retiring generation may be reluctant to take a step back and let the incoming generation make decisions and learn from the outcome, whether good or bad, allowing them to do so while there is still time to teach may be the most effective option. If incoming generations remain mindful and respectful of the experiences and vast knowledge of the retiring generation, the operation can become even more competitive and successful while the transition is still underway. Hard Work Pays Off Ultimately, succession plans can be as unique as the operations they direct. In fact, the more individually tailored they are, the more successful they are likely to be because the stake-holders invested significant effort in creating a plan to accomplish their collective vision. Producers investing the time and effort to create effective succession plans will help to keep American agriculture from

Chapter 12 Bankruptcy Rules of Engagement: Farming Operation or Not?

A man stacking blocks spelling out Rules on a table

Relief for Farmers Prior to 1986, a debtor intending to reorganize debts had two options for filing for bankruptcy: Chapter 11 or Chapter 13. Unfortunately, neither option was particularly well suited for family farmers. Chapter 11 provided a complicated and expensive route to relief, while Chapter 13 lent itself to reorganizing debt loads much lower than those often carried by farmers. Congress recognized the need for a more streamlined process for “family farmers” and “family fishermen,” and thus, Chapter 12 Bankruptcy was born, combining provisions already included in the Bankruptcy Code into a new structure that allowed farmers to continue owning and operating the farm while repaying all or part of their debts. Along with restrictions regarding the source and amounts of debt and income, the Bankruptcy Code requires that a petitioner be “engaged in a farming operation” to be eligible to file under Chapter 12. In spite of this limitation, farmers who have ceased the physical activity of farming but seek to file under this chapter may still have hope. In re Mongeau, recently decided in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Kansas, provides some guidance. Mongeau Case Study David and Jennifer Mongeau jointly owned and operated a large farming operation where they grew crops and ran cattle. As all too often happens with farming operations, what was once a profitable endeavor became much less so. The Mongeaus made the decision to complete a structured wind-down and began liquidating their farm assets in 2020. By the end of the year, they had ceased the vast majority of their farming activities and sold or otherwise transferred most property and leases to others. Notably, the Mongeaus’ family members purchased much of the real property and equipment, and that family members used the same equipment and the leases David and Jennifer had previously held in the family members’ operations. David and Jennifer continued to provide manual labor in helping on their family members’ farms despite winding down their own operations. On February 1, 2021, the Mongeaus filed their Chapter 12 petition. An unsecured creditor, American AgCredit, moved to dismiss the bankruptcy, claiming that the Mongeaus failed to meet the Code’s definition of being “engaged in a farming operation” and therefore were not entitled to file under Chapter 12. The Bankruptcy Court disagreed. As there was no dispute over the other Chapter 12 eligibility requirements, the Court looked only at whether the debtors were engaged in a farming operation on the date of filing. After discussing tests utilized by other jurisdictions and considering factors proposed by the parties based on relevant case law, the Court weighed five factors to determine whether the Mongeaus were engaged in a farming operation: (1) whether the debtors had abandoned all farming operations at the time of filing; (2) whether there was a plan or intent to continue farming operations in some form; (3) whether the abandonment of farming was a shift to a different type of farming; (4) whether debtors own farm assets such as equipment; and (5) whether the activities are subject to the cyclical risks involved in farming. The outcome of the factor test was determined by looking at the totality of the circumstances on a case-by-case basis. In evaluating the first factor, the Court looked beyond the narrow interpretation proposed by AgCredit and found ample evidence that the Mongeaus’ had not abandoned all farming operations. The debtors’ continued involvement in family members’ farms, care of their daughter’s cattle, and partial ownership of cattle equipment intended to be used in a future smaller scale livestock operation supported the Court’s finding. Beyond that, the Court also gave significant value to the business side of farming, noting that “managing the business elements of a farm are just as much farming as plowing the ground.” David Mongeau was still actively engaged in the business side of farming beyond the date of filing, as he continued to distribute their 2020 farm income to creditors as it came in from various sources. The Court spent less time discussing the other four factors. It evaluated the second and third together and found that the Mongeaus’ testimony regarding their intent to start a smaller-scale cattle operation with their brother, coupled with the concrete evidence provided by their involvement in the family farms and partial ownership of cattle equipment, showed a legitimate intent to continue farming of a different type. The Court looked to the debtors’ current ownership of a pickup, cattle equipment, and funds that arose from the sale of equipment and crops to satisfy the fourth element, and finally, the fact that the Mongeaus were “winding up the results of the risks previously taken” was enough to satisfy the fifth factor. After considering all of the circumstances surrounding the Mongeaus’ situation, the Court found that the Mongeaus were engaged in a farming operation when they filed their Chapter 12 petition, and were therefore eligible to be Chapter 12 debtors. Application Though the Court cautions that this case should not be taken as an endorsement of the Mongeaus’ methods, it does serve as an example of how farmers who have ceased the physical activity of farming may successfully establish that they are “engaged in a farming operation” and, by extension, Chapter 12 eligibility. The Court’s focus on Congress’s intent to help family farmers to continue farming and willingness to consider all facets of farming, not just working the ground or raising animals, leaves room for debtors to prove what activities constitute farming in their operation. As the Court points out, the inclusion of the simple word “farming” in the list of activities that satisfy the definition of “farming operation” allows for consideration of modernization and the changing processes that come along with it. As with any court case, supporting evidence is crucial. To have the best chance at success, a filer attempting to meet their burden of proof in establishing Chapter 12 eligibility after ceasing some or even all physical farming activities should not only be prepared to give testimony regarding their previous