Influencing Legislation: Putting Your Voice to Work for Laws

Be honest: What comes immediately to mind when someone talks about how Congress makes a law? For generations of Americans it’s the 1976 “I’m Just a Bill” episode of Schoolhouse Rock. It was a catchy introduction when we were young, but we soon learn there’s much more to the process than, “He signed you, Bill! Now you’re a law!” Your participation in democracy doesn’t have to end at the ballot box. You can tell your legislators what laws you’d like to see, or which you oppose. There’s an old saying that “if you don’t vote, you can’t complain”—the same could be said of legislation that passes, if you don’t share concerns with your members of Congress. My hope here is to help you effectively do that and feel comfortable doing so. If you already know the finer points of crafting legislation, you may want to skip over this next section. For everyone else, here’s a quick overview of lawmaking at the federal level. Journey from bill to law Any legislator can create and introduce a bill in their chamber of Congress, the Senate or House of Representatives. It is then assigned to the proper committee, which may hold hearings, conduct research, and possibly rewrite parts of the bill. If the bill is to advance and not just languish in committee, it needs to be voted out of committee to the full Senate or House—where the Speaker of the House or the Majority Leader of the Senate can decide whether to allow it to come to the floor for debate and a vote. The committee could alternately decide to just study the matter longer, or vote to kill the bill. One note on the above is that bills that expressly require federal funding must start in the House. Once on the full House or Senate floor, a bill can pass to the other chamber after it receives a majority of “yes” votes—51 in the Senate or 218 in the House. There are some rules unique to the Senate, however, that can put a snag in this process. One is the fact that any Senator, for any reason, can place a hold on legislation and prevent it from coming to a vote. Another rule is the filibuster, which is designed to delay the voting process. Under filibuster, a member can talk on the Senate floor as long as they like, about the bill or any topic, and no vote can be taken until they are finished. Cloture is a way around the filibuster—if a Senator invokes cloture and at least 60 members vote to agree on that, it ends all debate, filibusters, and holds and forces another vote on the bill itself. Probably the latest example of cloture at the writing of this article was on March 14 when several Democrats joined Republicans 62-38 to force a vote on the stopgap spending bill to avert government shutdown. For the sake of argument and to keep this short, let’s say the House or Senate does approve a bill and sends it to the other, but the second chamber makes some changes to pass it. This creates two versions, which must go to a reconciliation committee made up equally of Senators and Representatives. If they can agree on a single compromise version, that’s what goes back to both House and Senate for votes. Once both chambers have approved the same language—whether on first pass or through reconciliation—it goes to the White House, where the President has 10 days (minus Sundays) to sign it into law or expressly veto it and state their objections. If they fail to sign or veto the bill in that time, it automatically becomes law. A vetoed bill that can win a two-thirds “yes” in each chamber (67 in the Senate, 290 in the House) will become law… but this doesn’t happen often. One more note about veto power: If Congress sends the President a bill but adjourns before the 10 days is up, making the President unable to return an express veto, he or she can do nothing and kill the bill with a pocket veto. Congress can’t override this type of veto, so the process would need to start all over again with the introduction of a new bill. An example of ongoing advocacy For more than 30 years, I have been involved in federal legislative efforts both as a concerned citizen and an attorney who represents farmers. I have had successes, such as when I helped write legislation for Chapter 12 bankruptcy that addresses farmers’ unique concerns. And then there are issues that take longer to solve, which I continue to work on with legislators. One longtime cause is venue reform for bankruptcy cases. I believe large companies filing Chapter 11 bankruptcy should be required to do so in the court closest to where they conduct business, but there is a loophole in federal law that permits them to set up subsidiaries in other states with courts historically sympathetic to the specific relief the corporation desires. Having that subsidiary organized in a favored state allows not only the subsidiary to file there, but by extension, the parent corporation to be able to do the same—often far from their creditors. This tactic has been used to deny farmers and other creditors fair payment for supplies and services when massive corporate assets are liquidated. It happened when ethanol manufacturer VeraSun Energy, headquartered in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, filed its Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2008—in Delaware, a state notably lacking in ethanol plants or cornfields—leaving many Midwest farmers with grain contracts holding the bag. Just last month, crop ag-tech firm Benson Hill headquartered just outside St. Louis filed its Chapter 11 in faraway Delaware, as well. Why is this issue important to farmers? Bankruptcy proceedings happening several states away discourage creditors who can’t take the time or afford to travel from attending to testify or observe. Also, if I’m representing an Iowa farmer in a Delaware courtroom, we need to hire an extra lawyer who is licensed in that state
Terminating the Technicality: Venue Reform, Why It’s Important, and What You Can Do About It

Bankruptcy is a legislative creation aimed at giving debtors the opportunity for a fresh start while still recognizing the rights of their creditors to be paid. Chapter 11 Bankruptcy allows an entity experiencing financial distress, typically a corporation or partnership, to seek relief through reorganization, while retaining their business in hopes of generating revenue to pay debts as completely as possible. The debtor first files its bankruptcy petition and proposes a plan for repayment. Creditors are given the opportunity to vote on whether the plan is acceptable, and after considering those votes, the court may or may not confirm the plan. The expectation is that a company will file bankruptcy where it is actually located. Unfortunately, many large companies have found a way to circumvent the statutory requirements and file in a jurisdiction with which they have no meaningful connection in hopes of obtaining a more favorable outcome. The Technicality The current law requires an entity to file its bankruptcy in one of two places: (1) the district where the entity’s place of incorporation, residence, principal place of business, or principal assets in the United States have been located for at least 180 days or (2) the district where an affiliate of the entity has a pending bankruptcy matter. The second option is where companies found an opportunity for creativity. Say Company X wants to file bankruptcy in front of a judge who is historically more likely to accept its arguments. By setting up a subsidiary in that judge’s district, having that subsidiary guarantee the debts of the already-struggling company, and then having the subsidiary file for bankruptcy, Company X suddenly has an affiliate with a pending bankruptcy matter there, albeit a manufactured one. Company X is then legally entitled to file its bankruptcy petition in that judge’s district and potentially have its plan confirmed when other judges would have declined. Purdue Pharma’s Filing In re Purdue Pharma, L.P. is a textbook case of this tactic. Opioid manufacturer Purdue Pharma sought to use bankruptcy as a mechanism to compel acceptance of a global settlement by the plaintiffs in numerous civil actions brought against it and various members of the Sackler family who indirectly owned the corporation, as those were the company’s only major creditors. Among other things, its reorganization plan included what is known as a third-party release, which would shield the Sackler family from liability relating to Purdue’s role in the opioid crisis. Bankruptcy courts are split over whether third-party releases are an appropriate inclusion in reorganization plans, and those that allow them do so on a very limited basis. Appearing in front of the “right” judge in the “right” jurisdiction is paramount. Purdue recognized an opportunity and worked to get its matter into the Southern District of New York in front of the Honorable Judge Robert D. Drain, who had previously indicated an openness to entering a third-party release as part of a Chapter 11 reorganization plan. Over multiple creditor objections, Judge Drain approved Purdue’s reorganization plan, including the third-party release that protects the Sacklers from current and future litigation relating to the opioid epidemic. The bankruptcy plan sets aside funds for programs to be established by cities, counties, and other entities, as well as money to be paid to individuals affected by opioids after an adjudication process. However, holding members of the Sackler family liable for their role is no longer an available avenue. In exchange for paying a fraction of their estimated personal profits from the opioid epidemic over nearly a decade, the Sacklers have immunized themselves from further liability, despite objections from those harmed by the opioid epidemic. Exploitation The creative maneuvering employed by these companies, known as “forum shopping”, is an exploitation of flexibility purposefully built into the bankruptcy venue statute by its drafters, and Purdue is not alone in the practice. When the statute was adopted back in 1974, the committee fully expected that allowing companies multiple options for choice of venue would get the cases placed in the most appropriate court. This expectation rested on a belief that judges who found bankruptcy cases filed in their courts without a meaningful connection to the district would kick those cases to the court where it should have been originally filed “in the interest of justice or for the convenience of the parties” as they are authorized to do under 28 U.S. Code § 1412. The unfortunate reality is that judges tend not to exercise that discretion, and even if they do it often doesn’t occur until many of the most important decisions in the case have been made and after significant expenditures of money and effort by objectors. These realities only serve to encourage forum shopping. Termination Current legislation takes aim at closing the loophole and strengthening the integrity of the bankruptcy system while increasing public confidence and fairness. The Bankruptcy Venue Reform Act of 2021 (H.R. 4193), introduced in June of 2021, and the identical Senate bill (S.2827), introduced in September of 2021, acknowledge the practice of forum shopping and the resulting concentration of bankruptcy cases into just a few districts. The bill’s text also notes that not only does forum shopping prevent important stakeholders from fully participating in the bankruptcy process, it removes the possibility of the unchosen district participating meaningfully in the development of the bankruptcy law that will inevitably affect its constituents. In hopes of removing the enticement to forum shop, H.R. 4193 and S.2827 propose to add significantly more detail to the venue statute. Along with formatting changes that would make the statute more readable, the legislation includes important changes, including: specifically defining the term “principal place of business”; significantly limiting the option to file in a district where an affiliate has a case pending; placing the burden of proving correct venue on the entity that files the bankruptcy; and requiring cases filed in an improper venue be either dismissed or moved to the appropriate district rather than leaving it to the judge’s discretion. Leaving limited room for interpretation
